Discussion in 'Black Hat SEO Tools' started by BusinessMachine, Feb 17, 2010.
How do they compare?
I'm trying to understand what each one does in comparison to each other.
Would it make sense to buy both?
They both have different but very powerful uses. Scrapebox can do many handy things that Xrumer cannot do. Together they are crazyy
Xrumer is an old tried and trusted.
Scrapebox is new and exciting - i guess it needs to be harnessed carefully
if u buy xrumer u dont need to buy scrapebox, but it can be handy for little jobs
I am also told scrapebox is quite useful in conjunction with Xrumer should you wish to target specific PR sites... esp. seeing as Hrefer PR tool is 99.99% useless.
Never had the need to do that myself...
I think there should be a comparison tread posted here so that people will know and compare each tools. We could have a list of tools and show them by chart or something.
There are two other threads asking what is the comparion of these tools.
Is scarebox free ?
if not, what BH world "like" xRumer are free?
I would certainly go with xrumer. Its really great and awesome tool..
Applications are different, so you can't really compare them, scrapebox is based around blog commenting, xrumer is based around forum posting, if your on about which is more powerful, xrumer is generally more powerful.
BMD is bookmarking demon right? Sorry for the noob question lol..
Yes, it is.
It's very valuable.
ScrapeBox is not free and neither is xrumer. Since ScrapeBox is only $47 to BHW members ($97 to the rest of the world) the general consensus has been to just buy it. Also, xrumer is $540 one-time payment and no monthly charge for the first three months. After 3 months its $10/month. As xrumer is very powerful and complex no one has tried to duplicate it totally, at least I haven't found anything like it.
Again, the general consensus has been to buy xrumer. You can be assured that at the very least you definitely want xrumer in your **************. In fact, I think you could say that if you could only ever get one tool it should probably be xrumer.
Here are some links below to grab it up:
Affiliate Link, Cool People Only
Normal Link, Lame
OK, I also found the link for BHW members to get the discount to Scrapebox:
It looks like sweetfunny has raised the prices for BHW members. It used to be $47 but now when I check the link it is $57. In my opinion it is still worth the money. Even at $97 it is still an extremely powerful tool and worth the price.
Huh, it must have just bumped up to $57. I remember checking a little over a week ago and it was still $47. Anyways if you have the money for both get both. If you have the money for xrumer get that first. If you don't have the money for xrumer don't buy ScrapeBox.
Save up for xrumer and once it has started making you money invest into other tolls like ScrapeBox and bookmarking demon (I can not vouch for BMD both those I trust have). There are definitely others worth getting but xrumer is a must have.
The learning curve is very high for xrumer and it will take you some time master it. Better to just dive into it as soon as you can. Well, I hope this helps.
This sum it all... I love them both...
BMD,XR Nd SB Hell Yea i Got Them All
To tell the Truth SB Beats Hrefer to dust at least from my experience
but it cant stand a chance With XR.
And Bottom Line is It Depends On the User Not The Tools How Powerful They Are
So Those Two Rock MY Blackhat IM
You can xrumer of your home PC just as Scrapebox..
Xrumer is so much more powerful than SB but SB and UCWS are powerful too...
Take your time to know a tool before jumping on to the next..use it and knock yourself out...Right now I am combining all the three together and the results are simply amazing."WH killing"..they never have a chance against such tools
Cheers to the minds who create these tools. Long live Spam
Meh... unless there's a better way to use Xrumer than what I'm doing now I'm simply exhausted and confused... Xrumer hasn't even effected my SERPS the slightest bit. Scrapebox has, but it's possible that it was the late indexing of the bots of the backlinks. I'd love to learn how to use Xrumer properly but I really can't.
They do two different things. It's futile to compare them. No doubt, they both own at what they do.
well my choice is Xrumer.
BTW, 15/04/2010 a new version of Xrumer will be released...
Great news! It is not that far away!
Separate names with a comma.