redirect question

wwsosop said:

I am going to mess up bad i think on the if it aint broke dont fix it motto,

I have a site page one and ranking 1-5 all keywords needed.

I found a website with a backlink profile that is 10 times better than mine in a niche that is similar but not exactly the same. Talking nbc, abc and vice type links, my question is if I redirect these these links about 20-30 Rds, and they are way better than anything i currently have, could this hurt me?

I was thinking i should just rebuild the site to be safe and give self a link....

Click to expand...

RoyRoyan said:

Are you talking about a 301 redirect from an expired domain? I wouldn’t recommend doing that if your site is already ranking in the top 1–3. Adding such a powerful 301 redirect with a large number of backlinks could trigger Google to recalculate your domain’s authority and rankings. And that often leads to unpredictable results. It’s a big risk.

It’s better to create a new site on that expired domain targeting the same keywords.

Alternatively, you can restore the old content and place a backlink to your main site (like for a PBN). Just make sure to remove any potential fingerprints (don’t use the same GA, GTM, GSC, etc.).

Click to expand...

LavelLunatic said:

If you want to 301 redirect an authority expired domain with a good link profile that’s similar to your niche, then it can be a good move.

But since your current site is already ranking on page one and holding positions 1-5 for your target keywords, you need to be careful. A bad redirect—even from a strong domain—can confuse Google if the content or niche isn’t closely related, or if it's done too aggressively.

If the site you're redirecting from is not closely aligned with your content, it might be safer to rebuild it and give yourself a contextual backlink instead.

Click to expand...