the record companies are desparate for cash and appear to be suing everyone! 
Record Label Sues Developer for Using Open API
John Musser, February 26th, 2009Comments(0)
In what might be a first in the world of open APIs and mashups, a
developer has been sued by a major corporation for developing an
application using a third party web service API. As TechCrunch?s
Jason Kincaid reports, Ryan Sit, the talented developer behind a
number of popular mashups is being sued by EMI for his application
Favtape because it uses the Seeqpod API. Of course it?s not unusual
for a record label to aggressively use the courts to defend copyright,
but this appears to take the battle to a new ground. As Jason
describes:
It?s no secret that the record industry hates Seeqpod, a music site that
lets users stream songs for free. Last year the company was sued by
Warner Music Group (the outcome of the suit is still pending). Now,
the company has just been slapped with a complaint from EMI.
The legality of Seeqpod is murky. The company says that it doesn?t
store any songs, but instead streams them from countless music files
littering sites across the web. In effect, it acts as a powerful music
search engine with a media player built in. The record industry claims
that this is still illegal, and the new EMI complaint goes as far as to
say that Seeqpod actually does host some of these music files, at
least temporarily (which would strike a major blow to Seeqpod?s
defense if proven true).
What is surprising, and potentially very alarming, is the fact that Ryan
Sit was named in the suit for running the one-man startup Favtape,
which leverages the Seeqpod API to stream music.
The Favtape mashup itself lets you create playlists and stream them
from Seeqpod. It does not host any songs itself, instead retrieves
them from the API. The general consensus on Seeqpod and their API
was that if the RIAA or another organization (like EMI) sued Seeqpod
that the worst that would happen to any dependent mashup apps is
that they?d no longer be able to get music from Seeqpod.
Seeqpod is one of the music APIs that?s had some good traction and
as of now we have 16 Seeqpod mashups in our directory.
More good insights on this case come from Michael Robertson:
EMI?s lawsuit against Ryan is the first example of an API user being
sued for the actions of the host company. Dozens of web sites use
Seeqpod?s API including: Songerize, Songza, Streamzy, and
JustHearIt but Favtape had the misfortune to be in the record labels
crosshairs. If API users can be held liable it threatens how the internet
works. The internet is well, inter-connected - not just user to user but
service to service. If you can?t connect there is no internet. Of course,
it?s not just music services that connect. Some of the most innovative
developments are called mashups ?when two services are combined
together? like a crime database and a mapping service used to create
the Sexual Offender locator.
Content owners should have right to control where their property is
displayed on the net, but the right does not extend to holding liable
anyone who links to that material. Targeting the originator is sufficient
because if the source is removed all links or services depending on
that will immediately become invalid. If Seeqpod is found by the courts
to be a copyright infringement it will go away and immediately break all
links to it. API usage, like Favtape does, is like a sophisticated form of
linking or referencing which I believe is protected under the DMCA
512 safe harbor which makes it legal to link to material - even if it that
material may be infringing.
And as Michael notes in his post, we have nearly 50 music-related
APIs in our directory. It?s not easy for a developer to evaluate the risk
of using any one of them based upon the just how vulnerable each
may be to a music industry lawsuit.
This case has the potential to be a stifling precedent. We will follow-up
as there are more updates on this story to report.
Code:
http://blog.programmableweb.com/2009/02/26/record-label-sues-
developer-for-using-open-api/