Partial or Brand Domain For Low SEO

Say you're gonna make a big site for product reviews on many products.

Domain Options:

A: reviewdude.com
B: analysisdude.com

You're going to do minimal seo and each page will likely be titled ({product} review -- catchy secondary kw)

Url structure as follows:

A: reviewdude.com/scrapebox-review
B: analysisdude.com/scrapebox-review

In this case which would you waiver is the better option for ranking -- partial-brand domain (reviewdude) or brand domain (analysisdude)?

I know you typically want to avoid keywords in the domain as it bloats the url structure with duplicates of the keyword; ie: reviewdude.com/scrapebox-review/

Still, with minimal seo I'm not sure if its a pro to have it more optimized or a negative....what do the blackhatters think?