You need to fix the legals:
you have "disclaimer", but the text you put in there is actually "terms of use" ...
but what you need is
"Disclosure" not disclaimer - as in
FTC Disclosure
(because you are being compensated for promoting products)
here is a link to more info:
http://searchengineland.com/ftc-disclosure-and-your-blog-34789
here is one of those generator things (with NO endorsement of how legally valid it may be, but something should be better than nothing):
http://disclosurepolicy.org/generator/generate_policy
The captcha in your contact form is broken, and you should turn off comments on your contact and other legal pages.
Should I add ads to my site with it just being a review site and not an actual sales page or squeeze page?
You shouldn't be worrying about ads until you get some traffic.
Once you have decent traffic, the answer is to A/B test your traffic to see what works best.
For now, leave the ads off (it will be easier to rank your site without the ads, and if you're making no money from them anyway, why make things harder?)
Get Weekly FREE Tips By Signing Up!
wow, weekly free tips?
that's not an incentive to sign up, it's sounds like "sign up to receive my weekly spam!"
You need to offer something of value to get people to give out their precious email address. And you need more details about what you are offering.
About the theme:
One of the reasons the highCTR themes work so well to convert adsense is because
they are on-purpose made to be uncomfortable to read. When you actually WANT people to read your content, this is a bad thing.
Look at your blog - see how the text is very tight? you have a tight huge wall of text... I read everything, but I see your site and I can't bring myself to read what you've written. Text that you want people to read needs to be well spaced out.
The home page - you have the entire article on the home page rather than an excerpt and "read more" - making people click through to read more will improve your bounce rate. (so will adding an image to every story)
I don't believe there is a theme that will make EVERYONE happy
Who cares about happy? you are trying to improve conversions, and THAT you can measure. You are trying to find a theme that will convert well, and it may not look like what you have in your "vision". If you want to make money, let go of your feelings, and do what works. If this is for fun, do whatever you want.
I don't mean to sound harsh, but honest advice will save you tons of time and money.
