magic submitter - is it worth it?

criticalmess

criticalmess

Regular Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2009
Messages
237
Reaction score
212
Just saw the video @ their site, there is a nice drag & drop UI, looks promising, question is the subscription issue. 67 a month can get other tools, so why get this one?
 
Advertise on BHW
Exactly, you can get other tools and only pay once. Although, the monthly payment ensures that the software doesn't go out of date.
 
Magic Submitter is very good, i've used Rank Builder in the past, and Senuke/SenukeX, and i prefer Magic submitter. The learning curve may be a little longer, but the software is superior, so is the support, Alex Krulik the creator is very easy to reach and provides top class support.

Try it
 
Thanks for the replies!

Question is, does it really do what they claim in the video?

also, can I add my own sites or I have a limited pool of types/sites that I can use?
 
Have you tried seo link robot? It does the same as magic submitter (if not more) and you have the option to purchase a lifetime license or $47 a month...I have had it for a while now and I think its brilliant, gets constantly updated, new features added + support is great. You can also get a discount on the warrior forum.

I'm not affiliated with the product in any way, I just think its a great piece of kit.
 
I had Magic Submitter and yes I think it's worth it. If you have custom sites.. but for default sites, naw.. I wouldn't buy it
 
The short answer, yes.

Great software, constantly updated, friendly dev and a great support. What else can one ask for? :)
 
I purchased a $5 month long trial. And I will be keeping it.

It can be a bit tricky to learn but once you start using the campaign feature you'll be sold. It allows you to simulate organic link building by scheduling how many days you want it to run. Another big plus is the campaign reporting button. A couple of clicks and your customers can see daily work reports.

I have not dived into adding custom submission sites but that is just around the corner.

I say try it for five bucks if that offer is still live.
 
Yes it does really do as it claims in the video, but of course it's not as push button easy as it may sound. There is a very high learning curve especially for Designer mode (the main reason to purchase) when you want to add your own sites. Some sites that you set up to automate simply will not work unless you know some Regular Expression and can program it into the Exec code function. There is really no help or assistance with this sort of thing, you just have to contact the developer and wait for the solution. The support forums are weak and the user base doesn't really seem interested in building a strong community.

If you want to take the time to use Designer mode and program your own sites to automate then it is worth it, just be prepared to be frustrated every once in a while. In all honesty though for the problems it has (buggy often), it is still one of the best softwares out there for accomplishing this sort of feat short of actually knowing how to program your own softwares.

Compared to SENuke's 100 somethign dollars a month, MS is a much better deal with many more sites you can post to and a slightly more frustrating interface.
 
I just got the trial. I really want it to be a web 2.0 machine. That really seems to be what is hot right now for SEO anyway. Or to build diverse links to buffer sites, aka web 2.0s, blogs whatever. I'm still playing with it, seems like it could be awesome, only problem is that captcha sniper seems to suck for it, but then again captcha sniper isnt that great with anything but I still use it.
 
I used to think Magic Submitter was the best software available, it's much better then similar programs like SeNuke because it actually allows you to add in your own web 2.0's.

After trying out Zennoposter, however, I no longer use Magic Submitter. Zennoposter has more potential and is only a one-time fee compared to $67/month, which saves you a lot of money over the long run. The only aspect of Magic Submitter that is better than Zennoposter is that it is much more user friendly, but if you are willing to take the time to learn the tool, I would definitely recommend Zennoposter over Magic Submitter
 
What about SickSubmitter? Im choosing between Sick and Magic...which is better?
 
I prefer Sick Submitter over Magic Submitter.

I WAS a loyal customer to SS.... I subscribed to their monthly service since 2010, but cancelled my subscription just yesterday.
Why? Well, it's too slow.... and it will immobilize your computer because it is always opening windows in the background to do its thingy.
So you can't watch movies in full-screen or play games while your Sick is running.

But Magic Submitter is way slower than SS.

I did try Magic Submitter before because of its ability to create web 2.0 linkwheel and stuffs, but just recently SS can do the very same. Also, for just less than $20/month with frequent updates.
Only disadvantage I could see is that you have to scrape your own sites... and sometimes you might just wanna buy packets from other users in their forum. They do sell templates too, which enables you to build more backlinks in platforms that SS doesn't support. E.G: ELGG, Wiki sites (such as Wikka, Mediawiki and so forth), XOOPs, .etc.
 
Thanks BlackSeng. Im planning to run that software on VPS. As for scrapping, I prefer using my sitelists.
 
BlackSeng said:
I prefer Sick Submitter over Magic Submitter.

I WAS a loyal customer to SS.... I subscribed to their monthly service since 2010, but cancelled my subscription just yesterday.
Why? Well, it's too slow.... and it will immobilize your computer because it is always opening windows in the background to do its thingy.
So you can't watch movies in full-screen or play games while your Sick is running.

But Magic Submitter is way slower than SS.

I did try Magic Submitter before because of its ability to create web 2.0 linkwheel and stuffs, but just recently SS can do the very same. Also, for just less than $20/month with frequent updates.
Only disadvantage I could see is that you have to scrape your own sites... and sometimes you might just wanna buy packets from other users in their forum. They do sell templates too, which enables you to build more backlinks in platforms that SS doesn't support. E.G: ELGG, Wiki sites (such as Wikka, Mediawiki and so forth), XOOPs, .etc.
Click to expand...

Yeah, when you're running Sick V3, you are 99% unable to use your pc while its running but in Sick V4 you are 100% able to use your pc while Sick is running. Eventhough its still in beta, its working perfectly for me.

On topic: With custom templates with Sick, Sick definitely is a much better software than MS and at a better price too. However, MS is a tiny bit easier to use than Sick.
 
I purchased the 1 month trial of Magic Submitter for $5 today. Haven't had the chance to read the manual properly and go through all of its features yet, but I'll see how it goes for the month. OP, I suggest you try the same. Even if you don't like it after a month, you'll only lose $5.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top