Is copying competitors actually hurting our SEO strategy?

Sarah Mathews

Sarah Mathews

Supreme Member
Jr. VIP
Joined
Sep 1, 2009
Messages
1,228
Reaction score
314
Been doing link building for a while and one thing I have noticed is how easy it is to fall into the trap of copying whoever is ranking first.

You find their backlink profile and start targeting the same domains.
Then you look at their anchor text and try to follow a similar pattern.
You study their content and build something similar.
Then you take their keywords and add them to your own site.

But there is a problem, we can see what they have, but not necessarily why Google trusts them.A competitor might have years of link history, brand mentions, strong internal links, aged pages, etc. Just copying their backlinks doesn't give you all of that.

Lately I have been using competitor analysis more for finding weaknesses and missed opportunities rather than trying to clone their strategy.
How do you guys use competitor backlinks, as a blueprint or mainly to find opportunities they missed?
 
Advertise on BHW
I use competitor backlinks more as an opportunity map.

I look for gaps: relevant sites they missed, broken/lost links, unlinked brand mentions, weak referring domains, and topics where their link profile is thin. Then I build a strategy around my own site’s relevance and authority rather than trying to copy their exact anchors or backlinks.

Competitor analysis should answer “where are the opportunities?”, not “how do I become a copy of them?”
 
Sarah Mathews said:
Been doing link building for a while and one thing I have noticed is how easy it is to fall into the trap of copying whoever is ranking first.

You find their backlink profile and start targeting the same domains.
Then you look at their anchor text and try to follow a similar pattern.
You study their content and build something similar.
Then you take their keywords and add them to your own site.

But there is a problem, we can see what they have, but not necessarily why Google trusts them.A competitor might have years of link history, brand mentions, strong internal links, aged pages, etc. Just copying their backlinks doesn't give you all of that.

Lately I have been using competitor analysis more for finding weaknesses and missed opportunities rather than trying to clone their strategy.
How do you guys use competitor backlinks, as a blueprint or mainly to find opportunities they missed?
Click to expand...
I use competitor backlinks more as a gap-analysis dataset than blueprint. My simple workflow here as export referring domains, filter for relevance and quality, map links to target URLs, then compare anchor types to identify domains or topical areas competitors have covered that I haven’t. I then prioritize those gaps based on relevance and authority, rather than simply copying their backlink count.
 
The information I get from analyzing backlinks of my competitors, however, comes to me more in form of a map rather than a blueprint because their backlink profile tells me what is successful on the SERP, while the real strength lies in identifying gaps in their backlink strategy.
 
To be honest, lately I don't really spend much time looking at what competitors are doing anymore...

That's for my own personal projects though.

I'm just doing my own thing while making sure I'm doing all the right things and just take both the wins and losses and learn from them to improve things

That's the approach I've leaned on lately and it's less exhausting for me. It also helps keep me going longer with the projects I'm working on.
 
maybe will use competitor backlinks more as a gap finder than a blueprint!
If you just copy them you stay behind but if you spot where they are weak or under supported and build stronger signals there using your own thing with right intent, thats where you actually overtake them!
 
If it's a micro-niche, the domain ranks for a very small list of KWs
That's a lot of data to work with
 
personally i have come to identify something, when it comes to competitors just use the analysis to see miss opportunity or new trending keyword. Then draft your own path. Google seems to be rewarding original sites, with original content and backlinks
 
Interesting to see that most of the responses are pointing in the same direction , using competitor backlinks as a gap analysis dataset rather than a blueprint. thats how I see it as well. A competitors backlink profile is useful for uncovering patterns, but copying the exact links rarely means copying the underlying authority.

I would rather look at which links are genuinely contributing value, what linkable assets or relationships helped them earn those links, which relevant sites they havent captured yet, and where there are opportunities to build something better or different.Competitor analysis should give us direction and opportunity, not a checklist of domains to replicate.
 
Treating competitor backlinks as a blueprint usually backfires. Older domains have years of brand searches, mentions, and trust behind them that you simply can’t see in Ahrefs or other backlink tools. Copy their exact anchor text patterns or a bunch of old directory links and you can end up with a profile that looks pretty manipulative without any of that history behind it.

I usually treat a competitor’s profile more like an industry address book. It shows me which publications and resource pages are actually open to covering the niche. From there, I’d rather pitch an updated study or a genuinely useful tool and earn a clean mention than copy someone else’s old link profile.
 
The backlink doesn't know who wrote the article. What matters is whether the page earns trust, gets crawled, and fits naturally into the site's ecosystem. AI is just the keyboard.
 
You're spot on — blindly copying competitors often backfires because you're missing their unique authority signals. I use competitor analysis mainly to spot gaps: weak pages, underlinked content, or opportunities they've overlooked. It's better to learn from their failures than imitate their
 
Sarah Mathews said:
Been doing link building for a while and one thing I have noticed is how easy it is to fall into the trap of copying whoever is ranking first.

You find their backlink profile and start targeting the same domains.
Then you look at their anchor text and try to follow a similar pattern.
You study their content and build something similar.
Then you take their keywords and add them to your own site.

But there is a problem, we can see what they have, but not necessarily why Google trusts them.A competitor might have years of link history, brand mentions, strong internal links, aged pages, etc. Just copying their backlinks doesn't give you all of that.

Lately I have been using competitor analysis more for finding weaknesses and missed opportunities rather than trying to clone their strategy.
How do you guys use competitor backlinks, as a blueprint or mainly to find opportunities they missed?
Click to expand...
Competitor backlinks should be used just to find opportunities.
Their links do reveal good prospects, but one should rather look for gaps and build links in accordance with own site....
 
No how would it? You don’t just “copy” them you analyse what they’re doing - you do it and you do it better than them.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top