invent free open source communication tool

don6644

Junior Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2023
Messages
148
Reaction score
276
I would ask this in r/privacy but motherfucking reddit filters will remove my post for no reason.

I have an idea. I am sure it's not genius and lots of people have already thought about this. Good chance some programmer has already made this. encrypted communication. ok ya I know there is protonmail and signal and telegram but those are great until you find out they were just a honeypot run by your adversary.

my idea: you invent a new language and create a decrypter for it. so as a simple example d = s and o = 3 and g = y
so you write an email to your partner s3y and your partner plugs that into his decrypter and understands you wrote dog. then he composes his message and encrypts it and emails it to you.
your encryption has to be complex. of course it cant be a = 1 b = 2 c = 3 any dumb ass can figure that out.
does something like this exist? what are the limitations of this, security flaws?
 
That is called a Substitution Cipher: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substitution_cipher
It would not hold up to any sort of targeted decryption attempts. I know it often feels good to try and reinvent the wheel when it comes to encryption (security through obscurity and all that), but really it's better to stick to standards that have been tested by so many different academic institutions, like AES-256.
 
Security and privacy professionals have moved past this type of basic idea long ago and there are more advanced tools if this is something you are after. Google them and you'll see that your idea is like saying "let's move back to morse code" while there are tool available that range in complexity and reliability while the thing you are suggesting is actually still in use in some narrow use cases.
 
Steganography will inspire you to next level of thinking, but realize that agencies will destroy you unless you give them the info they want if something happens
 
This method is too simple, it's completely oudated. WW2 cryptography was more advanced than this.

I suggest you learn about public-key crypto:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public-key_cryptography
 
Seems like you want your own substitution cypher like someone else described. It's quite the novelty but pretty shite for real privacy. For that, you're better off using E2EE tools. Unless you can coordinate with a codebreaker or cryptographer, it might not be worth pioneering your own cypher for any serious use.
 
Back
Top