Hey, I've got a site that's #1 in G, Y, B, but the theme I am using is just not very good. No good places to place ads or videos or anything. I would like to switch to a sleeker magazine style theme but I'm afraid that if I switch my theme my site will fall in the SERPS. I've read elsewhere that changing a theme could lead to a penalty. My question: Can I switch my theme without penalty? Any of you guys had a similar experience? Thanks,
Not exactly a penalty but your site might start dancing and no one can tell when it will become stable, don't mess with the theme if its not that urgent...
It won't result in a penalty but your site position may change. I have experienced a great jump in SERP after changing theme but as you are at #1 spot it may be to risky...
I'll tell you guys what, I'll give it a shot and I'll get back to you. I can't monetize the site properly as it is currently set up.
There you go, nothing ventured nothing gained. You have a #1 rank site not bringing in bread but you feel a theme change with good ad placement will help... So what if it drops to #3 but you actually get sales? Then you can go back to getting it back up! Good Luck!
Exactly. Take action. Trial & error is really the only way to get a good grasp of SEO & SERPs. You can read up on it all you want, but you really dont start learning until you start using what you've read.
I know that everyone said that it's safe BUT I did get a penalty (+700) that lasted for 6 months. That being said, if I protected my site using robots.txt I would have made ti without penalty. See my theme was crappy and G indexed some of the words like "admin" etc to be the KW on my site and tried to rank me for those. Took me 6 months to repair the damage so all I can advise you is to make sure your robots.txt file is tight before making any changes to your site. Good luck
You will certainly NOT get a penalty. However changing the theme is likely to change the way headings are organized. Same goes for alot of other on-page factors which in the end will result in a changed on-page score. The site might slip off few positions. If you really need to improve the monetization I say do it, but make sure the new theme has exactly the same on-page SEO factors. The best way to do that would be to make a checklist with all the h1 and h2 headings and run it on the new theme. If something is missing, hard code it. good luck
definitely not....i've changed my website from Joomla to wordpress....so basically everything was changed on the website....but i kept the same links. The rankings were still the same, nothing was changed... As for wordpress templates...there's no reason to get serp penalties for that
Changing your template can screw you up. I made a post about it. Just google this ... Code: help rank dropped after changing theme
My rankings didnt change after a theme change. Also Terry Kyle says that there shouldnt be any changes after a theme change - although in posts of fellow marketers I sometimes saw a lot of dancing.
PHP, thank you for your comment and previous post. You wrote in a response to that post that: You also wrote that it's OK to change theme if: I'm really only changing the appearance of the site. Content, links, structure (and keyword density) will all stay 100% the same. I just need more space for ads otherwise the site will not be able to be monetized properly. This also isn't big dollars we're talking about here. If the site gets bounced, then I don't care. At the very least it will be a good experiment for everyone to see.
i also changed the theme, from thesis to some random one and nothing happened at all. still where i was before. website layouts are changing all the times, don't see why should that be an issue.
If you are already ranking #1 I wouldn't change anything just yet. It's not that Google will penalise you for doing it, but what you're doing at the moment is working for their purposes. A change - even one that's just cosmetic - might trigger the notorious Google Dance. If you want to change it, it might be worth keeping that under your hat for if your site falls from #1. I sympathise with your situation, I have run blogs that I've looked at and thought they really needed to be totally overhauled. But if people are visiting and you're ranking at the top of the big three search engines, then a change is more likely to make things worse than better. This way, at least you have a secret weapon if you need another boost.
