Yes, I was rotating Ip's every 1-12 minutes randomly.
Also I had about 8 web browser screens running their own identical bots to create 8 times the clicks on the link. for the first month I cleared my cookies and changed to show a random different browser upon each ip change.
The point is I moved it. However maybe i picked a bad target because forbes may not be treated the same as a less important link. The total clicks were about 4 times a minute x 8 screens 24 hours a day for over a month. That may be a drop in the bucket for forbes but not for that old story.
Still it wories me that google can see that for those 12 minutes all the clicks came from the same IP and web browser plus the same cookie was intact for that 12 minutes. I pushed through a few warning pages from google but I am unsure what is the point of getting sandboxed. Is it site dependent? was there a red flag tripped but they left it because it's a big news site? If so, why let me get away with bumping it up?
I think the value here is if you have a client that wants good search results not only for his site but his reputation, you could write articles and push them all up to flood the top 10 results.
Incidently, it may show as number 6 a small percentage of time but if you do ilke, 3 searches you may see it pop up mostly at number 1 or 2.
Any thoughts?