How I Pick a Niche, Analyze Competition, and Select Key Words

lightningblitz

Elite Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2014
Messages
1,920
Reaction score
4,714
This guide was requested by @DeadJoe , so I will try to reveal everything I do. My way is not the best way, but since everyone does do things differently, it cant hurt to see things from a new perspective.

How to Pick a Niche

The biggest time waste of getting started is knowing what niche to pick. When I started I used a very simple method of picking my first niche, I had a project I needed traffic for.

I started learning SEO because I already had a business / website. Dating niche. It all started from that point. I had to learn to analyze competition, do on page, and build backlinks.

After that project I was interested in SEO. So I tested on random web 2.0s. I bought some micro niche sites and tested.

I had very little to do in terms of picking my niches. I never really picked my niche for the first few years of IM.

By time I got serious and wanted a new large project I looked for the best domain I could find. I sought out domain auction sites to find the strongest and healthiest domains I could afford.

I avoided some niches such as tech, dating or a highly specialized field linke medicine. I knew I wouldnt be a good fit in those niches.

I know I got a couple incredible branded domains from a former seller on BHW, Howard Hughes. The domains had a few decent links but metrics were non existant. But the branded names were incredible.

Other niches I started by purchasing sites. One I still run today was from a seller on here, Napster. Another was from Frank, a former authority site seller on BHW.

None of the sites I bought were profitable off the bat. But it got me into niches.

Since most of these sellers are gone, there are a few new sellers that offer premium or expired domains. I know looking at their lists you can find great domains with strong metrics.

The only niche I selected myself is my most recent large project. It is a niche I am passionate about. A Niche I always wanted to be in, and knew a lot about. I waited until I knew enough about IM and SEO to be able rank high comp terms in a hard niche.

To recap:

1. I bought websites which already had a niche.

2. I found the best domain I could find and stuck with the niche.

3. I started a passion project.

I found that when I started I got lost in the Niche selection process. You can find decent keywords in any niche. To get out of my analysis paralysis I tossed a little money out.

My SEO testing were done on test sites with keywords of very high competition from my first niche. Dating.

My advice is to pick something you are passionate about or find the best domain possible and start in that niche.

How to Analyze Competition

My competition analysis all starts with knowing competition levels. Lets start with what I posted in my "How to Rank" thread in the BH SEO section.

Super Easy: Top 10 Results have no On - Page Optimization for the KW and are not strong domains.

Easy: Top 10 have a couple On - Page Optimization for the KW but they are not authority sites.

Relatively Easy: Top ten are all Optimized for the KW but no authority sites.

Medium: Top 10 has full On - Page Optimization and a couple (Maximum) Authority Sites.

Hard: Top 10 has more than three Authority Sites Optimized or three sites with an excellent backlink profile.

Very Hard: Top Ten has Six or More Authority / Strong Backlink Profile Domains.

This is general and years old. But it applies. Throw your keyword or niche into google, and see what you get.

I do have a few analysis tricks that serve me well. When trying to rank or doing back link analysis you will find things that do not make sense.

Most commonly it is in competition analysis. Commonly this is when you find a couple niche sites with a weak backlink profile in top ten ranking among some authority sites / large niche sites with a great back link profile.

I run the top ten through Ahrefs, Moz and Majestic to get the backlink profile.

When I find a site or sites that do not belong, I look at page two and three of google.

This is where things get interesting. If I find sites that have any of the following superior to the niche sites in top ten, I know something is up.

1. More very strong links.

I look for guest posts, authority site mentions, and an over all superior link profile.

2. Vastly superior content.

I look for better on page, at least 500 words longer, and more images with proper optimization.

3. Vastly stronger domain.

I look for a better root domain, with stronger internal linking.

If the pages look better, I know one of two things. Page one is using hidden links (PBN) or what I call Rank Suppression.

Rank Suppression was once my catch all term for when something should rank and doesnt. Now I use the term for pages or sites that are not ranking or should.

When I look into the sites on page two or lower I tend to find a few issues which cause supression.

1. Number one is insufficient links.
2. Poor CTR - Click through rate.
3. High bounce rate.
4. Bad meta description.
5. Missing niche links.

Number one means you need better links. Page one most likely has PBN links. I tend to avoid these niches.

2, 3 and 4 are all fixable. 5 is fixable as well. I tend to find that when I fix 2, 3 and 4 I rank or I know I am missing something. It most likely would be PBN links, but can be common links between page one.

Some niches have large authority sites that you need a link from to rank I dont know exactly why. I assume it is google trust.

I have seen these be specific niche directories, brand mentions from a large site, or even links as unique as practice review sites for doctor offices.

I find the links most of page one has and page two doesnt. The site then starts to move when those links are built.

Other signs of suppression are huge sites in page two or three. Like youtube, forbes, wikipedia, etc. These sites are missing a trust factor in googles eyes it doesnt have when Rank Suppression is occurring.

The rest of website analysis is basic. On page audit, and back link analysis using the big three tools. I always suggest all three as even using the free versions, you can discover a good amount. Other paid options like semrush can be superior.

How to Pick Keywords

I spent a lot of time with website analysis. That is how I do keyword research.

I tend to buy big keywords from sellers on BHW when I get stuck. But my Keyword selection always starts with competition scraping.

I typically use SEMrush. I put all the niche sites in my niche into SEMrush and then check the competition of each term.

This can be outsourced on fiverr for cheap.

After I scrape a website I look for pages that are ranking for a term that it is not optimized for. I then check SERPs and see if any sites have strong links.

If the sites are not optimized and few links, I know I have a golden keyword.

These are normally low search volume, but I dont care. I look for related keywords, long tails and LSI terms. I then write an article about all of the related keywords.

I firmly believe in leveraging the work of other SEOs to find good keywords.

Most people use KW research tools and that works for new niches or when you do not have competition to learn from. I just find it far easier using what others have done.

Putting My Process Together

I cheat when looking for a niche. I find the best domain possible and start at that point.

My competition is first about the basics. Then, if something doesnt make sense, I look for what ranking sites have in common. Things like backlink profiles and anchor ratios.

When something doesnt make sense, I look for what is missing.

Using this information I build my backlinks.

Using the same sites I analyzed I scrape what keywords they rank for with the least effort. I then target those terms myself.

These three steps are also the easiest way ti be successful. Start with a strong domain, build the links the best ranking sites have, and use the keywords the top sites are ranking for with little effort.
 
Thanks @lightningblitz - I'm a little weary of using expired domains for money sites. I've had some bad experience in the past.

Firstly, even if everything looks clean, you never know the domain might be penalized still. You may end up on page 2 but never hit page 1.

Secondly, i once bought a 1000 RD domain. Different niche, i repurposed it and set up a website. After a couple weeks all the links disappeared from GWT because Google noticed the niche was changed.

But that's just me. I know people do well with expired domains. I just have really bad luck with them Lol.
 
Thanks @lightningblitz - I'm a little weary of using expired domains for money sites. I've had some bad experience in the past.

Firstly, even if everything looks clean, you never know the domain might be penalized still. You may end up on page 2 but never hit page 1.

Secondly, i once bought a 1000 RD domain. Different niche, i repurposed it and set up a website. After a couple weeks all the links disappeared from GWT because Google noticed the niche was changed.

But that's just me. I know people do well with expired domains. I just have really bad luck with them Lol.

You are welcome.

When I look for expired domains I try to get one in the same Niche. For example, @Nargil has a health domain he registered / got at auction on his list. It costs 1k.

I have a big site in the health nice already and am tempted to buy it. Do I need it? No. But I know it has some great backlinks and is super niche relevant links.

That is the kind of domain I want to start a new site on.

In the past I would regularly check @accelerator_dd s list to find one niche related. 50 bucks to get a related domain with good links is a steal.

I still check the links manually. It is a gamble but normally I get a solid domain with all the branded and authority links I need.

That doesnt mean I dont use new domains, its just that a niche specific old domain is 10x easier.
 
Very informative and helpful. Thanks for sharing your experiences.
 
Thanks @lightningblitz for sharing. I've a question in the link building part > How much is the average price for your PBNs domains for easy to medium keywords ? I know it may depends on your competition but how much you pay for your auction PBN domains ?
 
Thanks @lightningblitz for sharing. I've a question in the link building part > How much is the average price for your PBNs domains for easy to medium keywords ? I know it may depends on your competition but how much you pay for your auction PBN domains ?

My network is mostly aged now and domains purchased a long time ago. But I also dont use my network often.

When I was buying domains more heavily I paid between 10 to 50 per domain, plus registration.

The problem is that has been atleast a year.

Now scrapped domains are harder to locate quality. I wouldnt even bother with a domain that is not clean, has 10 RD, TF / DA of ten. Those are minimums. I also aim for niche specific if possible.

In the market place these are at least 20 USD. Up to 50. Then you run the risk the domain is penalized. Although with a good provider you have a one out of hundred chance of that happening.

Higher than medium comp, I aim for auctioned domains with at least 100 RD. These normally start at $100 usd for domain only.
 
Awesome share again! One question though:

Do you believe in "sandbox" time? Since I read a lot of people claim its a real thing, say when you build a website, you cant expect very good rankings of all keywords and noticeable traffics, before lets says several months, 6 months/9 months, whatever, after the "sandbox time", your website keywords rankings and traffics will go up.

And do you think use an expired domain will get out of sandbox quicker?
 
Awesome share again! One question though:

Do you believe in "sandbox" time? Since I read a lot of people claim its a real thing, say when you build a website, you cant expect very good rankings of all keywords and noticeable traffics, before lets says several months, 6 months/9 months, whatever, after the "sandbox time", your website keywords rankings and traffics will go up.

And do you think use an expired domain will get out of sandbox quicker?

I think the sandbox is a combination of two things:

1. Domain Age is a ranking factor.
2. Delay in link value.

One is self explanitory. A parasite ranks quicker than a new domain.

Two is the "wait six weeks for a PBN link to work".

When I started SEO I belived in the sandbox. Now I think I just wasnt good at SEO. The sandbox can be a lot of things.

New links have a delayed effect. Google dance as google is deciding if your site deserves a jump in rankings. Poor link velocity (one day you get 30 links, then dance begins and you stop building links) is huge.

I wont say the sandbox isnt real. I find three months is a good warm up time, but I start building some links day one.

But in general, if better sites were linking to your money site (a wikipedia link, a forbes link, a huffington post link, a cnn link, a foxnews link, and a ny times link) do you think google would wait six to nine months to rank you?

Not a chance.
 
I wont say the sandbox isnt real. I find three months is a good warm up time, but I start building some links day one.

But in general, if better sites were linking to your money site (a wikipedia link, a forbes link, a huffington post link, a cnn link, a foxnews link, and a ny times link) do you think google would wait six to nine months to rank you?

Not a chance.

Thanks for your input again! We all really love your threads.
 
Thanks for great Share.i have questions about keyword selection if Forums like reddit,quora etc Ranking on keyword should i go for it ? 2nd i want to target one longtail keyword for Example best gaming laptop for student and in serp top ten sites are not optimize for this keyword But these sites are Targeting best gaming laptop Should i go for it? Sorry for Bad English. And thanks in Advance
 
Another one?

Killing spree!

giphy.gif
 
This is a great post thank you very much.

Okay I am going to ask a few noob questions so please bear with me...

Where would a safe place be to look for deals on safe non penalized expired domains? And I'm not talking about one's for $1,000 the ones that are 20 40 $50?

And when it comes to buying keyboards from reliable source do you have a recommendation? Again as a noob I don't have a lot of experience with keyword searching but I don't want to waste my time getting keyword from somebody who really doesn't know what they're doing.

I don't mind paying for good product but I paid to have a website built by someone in the marketplace and it turned out to be just a royal piece of crap and a bad experience.... so I'm a little Leary now about where I spend my money
 
Thanks for great Share.i have questions about keyword selection if Forums like reddit,quora etc Ranking on keyword should i go for it ? 2nd i want to target one longtail keyword for Example best gaming laptop for student and in serp top ten sites are not optimize for this keyword But these sites are Targeting best gaming laptop Should i go for it? Sorry for Bad English. And thanks in Advance

I wouldnt touch that keyword. I ran through a couple keyword checkers and competition was medium to high.

The sites you are going against, although they are not perfectly optimized, are still your competition.

A lot of the sites ranking for best laptop for students which appear in serps for best gaming laptop for student contain a laptop in the review articles specifying the keyword.

The websites may not have
best gaming laptop for student in the title or URL, but they have enough about your keyword to rank.

Not all long tails are low comp. Especially since the hot SEO trend for a couple years is long tails.

And most SEOs know hyper targeted traffic converts better.

Some long tails are a lot easier. Others? Harder.

This is a great post thank you very much.

Okay I am going to ask a few noob questions so please bear with me...

Where would a safe place be to look for deals on safe non penalized expired domains? And I'm not talking about one's for $1,000 the ones that are 20 40 $50?

And when it comes to buying keyboards from reliable source do you have a recommendation? Again as a noob I don't have a lot of experience with keyword searching but I don't want to waste my time getting keyword from somebody who really doesn't know what they're doing.

I don't mind paying for good product but I paid to have a website built by someone in the marketplace and it turned out to be just a royal piece of crap and a bad experience.... so I'm a little Leary now about where I spend my money

Expired domains?

Two people still sell on BHW I have used. @Nargil and @accelerator_dd . I will be honest, I have not looked at accelerators stock in a year. I have looked at nargils premium stock in the last week. I found some domains I wanted to buy despite the fact I dont need them.

I personally trust Nargil. I also have used a few of accelerators domains as money sites, pbn domains and 301 redirects.

For keywords, you have a few options. Sadly, since I was tossing a lot of money around several guys have left.

I have used @nihalsad and get a list of lowish keywords consistently. I am currently waiting on reports from other sellers.

The best bet, and always will be, is to scrape a competitors ranking using SEMrush. Find a site (or ten) in your niche. Scrape all keywords they rank for.

I look for keywords ranking when the URL does not include the keyword or any variations. This usually means they are not targeting the term, and thusly if I optimize an article for the term, I steal their traffic.

I do this over a few sites and start with keywords in common. If multiple sites are getting traffic from a keyword yet none are targetting it, I consider it a safe bet.

I then run the keyword through a competition analysis tool and I manually check top 20 of serps. I look to see if anyone is targeting the keyword and just not ranking.

After all this, I can guarantee I have a famtastic keyword. I then run a check for long tails.

For no comp long tails with over 100 searches, I try to include it in the article, as an h tag (usually h3 or lower) and as an image alt text.

Anything under 100 I save for web 2.0, pbn and guest post content. See, I want my tier one links to rank for something related.

Keyword research is one of the few areas you cant pay someone enough to make you a millionaire. You can make some money but the best keywords will be taken. I find it best to leverage other peoples work.
 
How do you rank a site which is stuck at page-2 ? Most of my sites are stuck at page-2 so I'm trying to figure out how to bring them on page-1.

Thanks in advance!
 
Last edited:
That is a loaded question. It can be a lot of things. Normally:

1. Insufficient backlinks
2. Poor ctr
3. Poor bounce rate
4. Poor onpage

Its normally one or four. Two and three are about moving up page one.

I am willing to bet you have a worse backlink profile or most of page one share a back link or type of backlink you need. Commonly a real PBN.
 
@lightningblitz since you said you dont utilize your PBN as much anymore, do guest posts give you a similar boost? Especially since you get a link from a fresh article that is not on the homepage.

And, do you build links to your outreached links? If so, don't the site owners get pissed for that?
 
I have already picked my niche, so I read only second part: How to Analyze Competition. The post is really helpful, thanks!
 
That is a loaded question. It can be a lot of things. Normally:

1. Insufficient backlinks
2. Poor ctr
3. Poor bounce rate
4. Poor onpage

Its normally one or four. Two and three are about moving up page one.

I am willing to bet you have a worse backlink profile or most of page one share a back link or type of backlink you need. Commonly a real PBN.

That's a lot of knowledge for me. Noted this! Thanks a ton.
 
I wouldnt touch that keyword. I ran through a couple keyword checkers and competition was medium to high.

The sites you are going against, although they are not perfectly optimized, are still your competition.

A lot of the sites ranking for best laptop for students which appear in serps for best gaming laptop for student contain a laptop in the review articles specifying the keyword.

The websites may not have
best gaming laptop for student in the title or URL, but they have enough about your keyword to rank.

Not all long tails are low comp. Especially since the hot SEO trend for a couple years is long tails.

And most SEOs know hyper targeted traffic converts better.

Some long tails are a lot easier. Others? Harder.
Got it.Thanks a lot
 
Back
Top