How do you rate this content?

PaulRD

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2018
Messages
1,017
Reaction score
460
Just quick read and feedback would be so much appreciated. It is a satirical content:

Scientists Report Most Effective Remedy For Male Depression Is An Old Lady At The Store Asking You To Reach Something On A Tall Shelf


Staff at the Brookhaven Institute of Mental Health were left stunned Monday after a peer-reviewed paper concluded that the “most potent cure” for male depression is a “well-meaning elderly woman” requesting assistance with a top-shelf grocery item.

The study, published in the Journal of Comedic Psychiatry, claims interactions involving “small-statured seniors” and “lightly out-of-reach canned goods” triggered a 94% drop in symptoms among test subjects. “It’s the helpless smile, the ‘young man’ honorific — pure dopamine,” said lead researcher Dr. Felix Greaves, who was promptly accused of “ignoring 50 years of real science” by rivals.

Outrage erupted when the paper suggested replacing antidepressants with “strategically placed short grandmothers” in supermarkets. “This is pseudoscience!” shouted one critic, later revealed to be a disgruntled therapist whose clinic had just invested in $200,000 worth of unused couches. “Next they’ll say knitting mittens cures PTSD!”

Supporters fired back. “My husband hasn’t smiled since 2018,” said study participant Linda Cartwright, clutching a photo of her spouse beaming beside a jar of marinara sauce. “Now he hangs out in the soup aisle like it’s a spa.”

The findings gained traction after viral footage showed a man in Nebraska weeping joyfully while retrieving a can of chickpeas for a woman named Edith. “I felt… needed,” he told reporters, adding that he’d “forgotten what purpose felt like” since his kids stopped calling.

Critics argue the study’s methodology was flawed. “They only tested men who already owned ‘Dad Vibes’ t-shirts,” grumbled one psychologist, who then stormed off to rearrange his own pantry.

Matters escalated when lawmakers proposed a bill requiring all stores to stock “at least one unattainable shelf item” per aisle. “This isn’t healthcare — it’s socialism!” yelled a talk radio host, moments before an 82-year-old listener asked him to grab a cereal box mid-rant.

At publishing time, the American Psychiatric Association had threatened to sue, while Walmart announced plans to train employees as “shelf-related self-esteem coaches.”
 
I could not bear to read after the headline.
:D I took that headline from babylonbee and structured the satirical content to see how does the content do
 
Satire is tricky, reactions confirm it. Vital question: does this style resonate with *your* specific audience and achieve *your* content goal? Cleverness without connection doesn't drive results.
 
Yeah, wouldn't read past the headline for this one.

Maybe a headline like:
How Will Helping An Old Lady Cure Male Depression?

Little bit shorter, so it's not as tiring to read, (shorter attention spans nowadays anyways so it doesn't hurt). It also adds a bit of clickbait with a half answer, or more accurately an extremely summarized answer.

That way you would be able to better drip in the answer throughout the article which would mean a longer reading/ stay-on-page time for your article (if that's your goal).

Right now there's no incentive to read past the headline, which is great if that's the intention, though I don't think many would want their readers to only read the headline. You could look into 'reverse pyramid writing', which could help with structuring the article a little better, as right now it looks more like a 'T-shaped' article, where the main bulk of the content is in the headline, with little to no 'important' content below.

Maybe you could look into TheOnion articles, which I think do a pretty good job of attention-grabbing headlines that get readers reading.

Just my two cents, hope it helps.

Used to study comms / journalism etc. in school so I hope the knowledge isn't too outdated.
 
Back
Top