I think we should be allowed to choose giveaway winners based on 1) Random Selection - To eliminate Giveaway squatters/leechers. There are tons of people that just wait on giveaways and attack like hawks! If it was random selection everyone will get a fair chance to win the giveaway. and/or 2) Based on what they will do with it. Say I were to giveaway 5 Super High PR Authority Links. Someone with no SEO experience who doesnt value the links comes in and says he wants it. According to the rules since he asked for it first I have to give it to him. However, it will be a complete waste of the giveaway and the person wont use if effectively. Just my thoughts. If anyone agrees with me or has a point of view regarding this please post below.