Email Extractor vs. Email Spider vs. ???

I want to start harvesting emails based on keywords, and I'm hoping for addresses for ordinary people, rather than webmasters and company reps.

I did a search on here for email extractors, and I tried three of them: Email Extractor 14, Email Spider, and emailscraper (a script that runs in iRobot). I couldn't get the last to do anything, so it looks like it's between EE14 and ES.

For the kind of addresses I described in the first paragraph, do you think EE14 or ES is best? If EE14, is it twice as good (like the price)? Or would you recommend something different?

I can't really test the effectiveness of what I want to do, because in the "free" mode, neither of these programs allow you to save the results. I don't mind paying for a program that's going to make money for me, but I sure wish I could give these programs a full test.

TT

which of those email extractors did you go with. I too just tried free version..hard to tell

Its very difficult trying any of them in the free demo version mode but after much thought i purchased this one http://emailextractorpro.com/ which cost approx 30 euros ( around 50 bucks) as it does what i want to do and does it well.
I was in between with choosing the one you indicated above Email Extractor 14 but decided against as the price is much more to begin with and i could not see much difference in the tool except for speed.

Email Grabber is really good (support keywords) :

Beny

Interesting idea. I wonder how email extractor gathers information?