i think this site should be invite only.
but it also should be open to new members, its important for new blood to stumble onto the scene. if it wasn't available to new members, probably NONE of us would be here right now unless you were a member the day the site initially launched.
i think it should go something like this: the forums should be closed off to the public, it should be 90% be jrVIP or higher. Invite only. 10% will be able to be accessed by people invited to it, but they can still not get to the main parts (jrVIP and higher) even though they are invited to the forum, they still have to get to the next phase. none of it will be open to the general public without an invite.
a second (very small) site setup with only a couple of forums. these are the threads people will see in the search engines. it will be the breeding ground.
people can post all the questions and stuff and answers and ideas they want on there. when the mods there see a diamond in the rough, they invite them to the main board. simple as that.
it will keep the main site smaller and easier to manage, im sure. its way too large right now, its probaby impossible for anyone to read every single thread. i know i dont anymore, theres just way too much stuff, and most of it is pointless. take a look, how many threads with the same exact info over and over again do we really need, because someone was too lazy to search for the answer. a day dont go by that i dont see threads dedicated to meta refreshes. enough already. more people would post more useful help and information if they could find threads worth posting in easier by not having to waste 45 minutes digging through threads of crap
and i also think it should have a small monthly fee for the main site, to pay for both sites to keep them running.
so i dont know how i should vote, i vote for private AND for a fee, AND keeping it open