blog comments not getting approved

I scraped a bunch of blogs relevant to my niche. I manually commented. I tried to make my comment sound legit. My comments go something like this:
I have [a certain problem]. I tried [x] and [y] and it didn't work. I found this website which claims they can solve my problem, their url is [my url], do you know if they are legit? have you ever used them?

Not a single comment got approved. WTF?

how do you increase your approval rate?

Sounds very scammy.

I have an itch to click Disapprove button.... (going to my blog after this)

1)
You are pretending your site is a 3rd party site. It's obvious. So stop that.

2)
Try to comment (or literally quote) a short part of the source article and comment on that. Ask a question.

3)
Make your name a link. People don't like links within comment body. (I sure don't)

4)
Make longer comments.

5)
Use friendly, personal custom email hosted on your own website.

Bad:
[email protected]

Good:
[email protected]

6)
Start a conversation without a link. Link further down the line in your 2nd+ response. Once you are BFFs with the webmaster

In other words (as per the prior post) try to look like you are actually responding to the content on their page, instead of clearly looking like you are only intruding on their property to pump your site. If you really believe the site page is relevant to your page, act like it by adding value---respond to the article in a substantive manner, and reference your site not like a plug, but like it adds to their site. You can say it like, "for more info that backs up what the author is saying on this subject, you can look at my recent blog post about this article..."

I dissapprove those very same comments all day long. Sounds like you just scraped some scam post and based yours on that. Try to add something to the website. Give back a little in order to get approved. There is no such thing as a free lunch.

Here's the TEMPLATE I use

Quick 1 line summary of the point you're making with the comment

Discuss one key part of the original post (the post you're commenting on) - QUOTE IT and comment on it

TIE your comment to a QUOTE from the article you're promoting

Explain why the snippet makes sense

Fully explain your MAIN point

Call the reader to action, "to see the full range of issues, see (URL)" - use something like that. Don't just drop the link.

Conclude

This makes your comment VALUABLE and ENHANCES the original post you're commenting on

The blog admin/owner would be more than happy to PUBLISH your post WITH your link.

firstnamelastname said:

"I found this website..."

Click to expand...

After just 4 words I consider the blog comment as spun Scrapebox spam. Block + trash.

Why don't you try auto or approved blogs.

blackbeans said:

Here's the TEMPLATE I use

Quick 1 line summary of the point you're making with the comment

Discuss one key part of the original post (the post you're commenting on) - QUOTE IT and comment on it

TIE your comment to a QUOTE from the article you're promoting

Explain why the snippet makes sense

Fully explain your MAIN point

Call the reader to action, "to see the full range of issues, see (URL)" - use something like that. Don't just drop the link.

Conclude

This makes your comment VALUABLE and ENHANCES the original post you're commenting on

The blog admin/owner would be more than happy to PUBLISH your post WITH your link.

Click to expand...

Now this is a good template! Thank you!

If this blog has no comments, then it's usual practice.
They accept comments, but not publish them.

If this blog has other comments, then your comment wasn't accepted because of link included.

I'd suggest you to post a comment that's relevant to the blog post. I've used scrapebox with this technique and got success at getting comments approved even from the manual approved blogs. Here's how I create relevant comments in bulk.

Let's say I am creating blog comments on blogs related to weight loss. I usually go to foreign language website, mostly spanish, as it has best translation in Google translate, and copy articles related to weight loss. Then translate them to english using online translator. And do little bit or modification to make them sound like comments, like using words like "I believe, then the article content" or "I totally agree with you, and then the Article content". I don't use whole article as the comment. I break down the articles paragraphs to convert them to multiple comments. This way I get hundreds of relevant comments by using just 20-30 translated articles.

This way I get many comments approved even when using blog comment softwares like Scrapebox. But, I make sure to scrape and use only blogs that are related to the niche.
To make sure blogs are relevant. I scrape the blogs using scrapebox. Then do a "Meta tag scrapping". Then on Excel I filter the blog URL, Title, description, and keywords , individually for hte keywords I am looking for. This way I get the most relevant blogs to my niche to comment.

One more thing. It helps to actually care instead of just focusing on the backlink you're getting.

Focus on branding.

Pretend you're writing to people whose trust you're trying to earn.

Pretend you're the blog owner-what kind of comment would YOU approve?

A little bit of value goes a long way when everyone else is trying to get a lot for as little work as possible

It is better you can write every time your own comment and provide link in the "Name" section instead to the comment box.