Beehiiv or Substack

blackbeans

Elite Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2008
Messages
9,247
Reaction score
4,794
When building a newsletter using posts to social media, which do you prefer: SUBSTACK or BEEHIIV?

Beehiiv requires a typical "sign up to my newsletter'" marketing approach. Upside: more flexible / 'spiced ham' marketing friendly :) Downside: more steps / more obvious.

Substack uses "if you like this content, join my newsletter" approach. Upside: your content does the heavy lifting of recruiting. Downside: not very flexible.

What do you guys think?
 
When building a newsletter using posts to social media, which do you prefer: SUBSTACK or BEEHIIV?

Beehiiv requires a typical "sign up to my newsletter'" marketing approach. Upside: more flexible / 'spiced ham' marketing friendly :) Downside: more steps / more obvious.

Substack uses "if you like this content, join my newsletter" approach. Upside: your content does the heavy lifting of recruiting. Downside: not very flexible.

What do you guys think?
depends on your audience if you’ve got a warm crowd substack works but if you wanna test and tweak beehiv seems better right ?
 
depends on your audience if you’ve got a warm crowd substack works but if you wanna test and tweak beehiv seems better right ?
For my next project I'll be sharing snippets of content.
 
i’d say if you already have a warm audience substack is great you just post your content and people subscribe right away but if you’re starting out or want to test different strategies beehiv gives you more options to tweak and adjust along the way you can also test both on a small sample to see which works best for your project
 
depends on your audience if you’ve got a warm crowd substack works but if you wanna test and tweak beehiv seems better right ?
I’ve been playing around with both recently too, and I agree, Beehiiv gives way more control if you’re doing anything beyond basic publishing. The tradeoff is that it feels a bit more “marketer-y,” which can turn off some audiences depending on your niche.

That said, if anyone’s thinking of trying Beehiiv, I found a 20% off code that worked for my first few months. Just figured I’d share in case it helps:

Screenshot below if anyone wants to use it:

Curious what others are using too — anyone tried Ghost?
 

Attachments

  • Beehiiv Coupon Code.webp
    Beehiiv Coupon Code.webp
    10.1 KB · Views: 3
if you want deliverability go for substack hands off, and if you want website go for beehiiv,

personally I use both, but I prefer convert kit over beehiiv
 
Back
Top