For high volume adult pop push campaigns, I will compare these three things no matter what the cloakers is
1. Filtering Accuracy: This is all about checking false positives, proxy ASN detection, and bot scores.
2: Speed Of Redirection: I want to look in cloakers for extra latency that can kill conversion on pop traffic.
3. Tracking: I will track everything that is possible, including ROI by geo and source.
I suggest AdSpect or Traffic Guardian, and test run a small traffic split before committing.
A cloaker alone won't solve all your problems, mainly the poor traffic quality or the compliance issues.
I suggest you to get started with a small campaign and then scale on it.