A little update
Sadly, revenue is still pretty low, mostly because of the low number of outbound clicks from Pinterest. I've been looking into why, especially since I've already created thousands of pins across multiple accounts, and I have a hunch why...
Some stats:
- Automated accounts: 88
- Unused accounts: 60
- Banned accounts: A few, but most get unsuspended.
- Affiliate sources: 2, both offering RSS feeds that I use for automation. (1 POD site and 1 e-commerce site)
- Total revenue: About 80 bucks (since I started this post)
Is it possible to generate traffic and sales on Pinterest with direct affiliate pins?
Yes, but there are some red flags I need to address:
When I look at my accounts, most of them get no more than 2K monthly pin views. That's a little odd, so I've been trying to figure out why.
My guess is that Pinterest is limiting my reach because of several factors:
- Repetitive content, with lots of similar products (not the exact same links).
- Posting links with the same domain
- Direct affiliate links (product pins/commercial intent pins).
- Not using the account like a real person.
- Although, this isn't necessarily true, I'm a Pinterest user myself, and I also automated my personal Pinterest account. But my monthly pin views have been slowly but consistently going down this year.
- Maybe some other signals that might make my accounts look spammy.
These are just educated guesses. I don't know exactly how Pinterest's algorithm works, but based on my experience with SEO and YouTube, I can understand why Pinterest might not like someone creating hundreds of accounts to post direct affiliate links.
My biggest problem is that this makes scaling difficult. I do get some traffic to my affiliate links, and since I'm using two affiliate sources, there's still a chance of making sales. One offers high-ticket products with commissions of at least $40 per sale, while the other has a 30-day cookie window.
Still, I'm starting to wonder if this method is worth the effort.
Trying a different approach
Alongside this, I've been testing a similar but slightly different method: running a semi-automated Pinterest account connected to a blog.
I bought a domain, started publishing AI-generated content, and began creating higher-value pins to drive traffic to the blog.
So far, this approach seems to be doing better. At least the numbers are going up instead of down.
The funny part, I even got indexed (without any backlinks) and started ranking on Google pretty fast, faster then expected. Still, its nothing impressive yet...
What's next?
I'm still planning to set up the remaining 60 accounts I've already created. After that, I'll see what happens. Hopefully, Pinterest will give some of my pins more exposure, and maybe I'll even get a viral pin or two.
I know Pinterest is slow, so maybe I get lucky, but, i'm pessimistic about that...
One other thing I've noticed is that new accounts seem to get a lot of impressions when I first start posting. But after a while, the reach drops again.
My guess is that Pinterest initially gives new accounts some exposure, then starts limiting them once it recognizes the repetitive content and strong commercial intent.
Again, that's just my theory, but it's an interesting pattern I've noticed so far.
-----
If anybody has any tips or suggestions (especially regarding directly posting affiliate links on Pinterest), I'm open to them.