Is anyone getting good reach but less followers on Instagram ?

agree that cause reach seems easier to get than actual followers cause to attract them to follow it may require other components. people would watch, like, and but dont spend time to visit the profile, they only watch the profile and consi to follow when the content gives them a strong reason to follow
 
Advertise on BHW
Growth Navigator said:
Some of my reels are getting decent reach and views but the number of new followers coming from the reach is very lower. A video performs well, get likes and shares but no new followers.

Previously, a reel with similar performance would result in the increase of new followers.

Has anyone else noticed this recently ? What do you think causing it ?
Click to expand...
Sure, that is what I see as well. It looks like Insta is trying to show users more content even from people who do not follow you, but whether they will follow or not will depend on how well your profile and niche are set up.
 
Same pattern here across a few accounts. Most of the reach IG is handing out now is reels-feed / explore traffic - people surfing, not hunting for accounts to follow - so follow intent on that reach is basically zero no matter how good the view count looks.

What used to drive follows was a reel making someone think "who is this" and tapping through. Now the algo is happy to just feed them the next video without ever routing them to your profile, so a viral standalone reel that's complete in itself gives them no reason to chase more.

Two things that have actually moved the needle for me:
  1. Put the account identity inside the reel itself - first 2-3 seconds plus on-screen handle/text, not buried in the caption.
  2. Make the first 3 pinned reels on the grid deliver the exact same thing that went viral. If someone does tap through and hits mixed content, they bounce.

And split the metric like marcotwzrd said - profile-visit rate vs visit-to-follow rate. If visits are up but follows are flat, it's a profile problem, not a reel problem.
 
I think what you should focus on to have enough information to evaluate more correctly is to having different type of content on different accounts.

The more accounts and certain type of content on it would help you understand better what's actually works in certain niche of content.

A few accounts would not provide you enough information to analyze whether or not the content is not working or not, but to have more accounts with different formats of video will be much more informative for you to learn about it.
 
thats not a bug, its reach and follow being two different decisions. a reel going wide means the CONTENT cleared the bar, low follows off that reach means the content didnt make anyone need more of YOU specifically. usually its content that performs as a standalone hit but has no personal thread pulling people to the profile, no reason to expect the next one to be as good. viral-but-anonymous. fix is on the profile side and the reel ending: give a reason to follow, not just a reason to watch. good reach is actually the hard half solved, dont waste it.
 
Growth Navigator said:
Some of my reels are getting decent reach and views but the number of new followers coming from the reach is very lower. A video performs well, get likes and shares but no new followers.

Previously, a reel with similar performance would result in the increase of new followers.

Has anyone else noticed this recently ? What do you think causing it ?
Click to expand...
Most reach today is by way of people who jstt consume content and then move on. Normally, I analyse profile visitations and why the person will choose to follow based on the Reel. When there is only 1 problem solved through content without generating interest, views will not lead to followers.
 
duke1921 said:
Don't worry about that, because nowadays with the new IG algos even having followers doesn't mean much, if the reels generally don't perform well, it won't be shown to the people who are following you, but if it does, it'll get shown to everyone, including the ones who are not following you. So, it doesn't matter either way. Just focus on reels getting more reach, and try converting from reels to DMs, via that current on the hype method, comment to DM thing.
.
Click to expand...
Yeah totally agree, followers are just a vanity metric nowadays.
 
your reel is being shown to cold viewers who like/share but aren’t your audience, so follow rate stays low
 
You should have good content so that people follow and reach increase
 
Having many views doesn't necessarily mean having many new followers. If viewers visit your profile but don't see a clear topic or value, they're less likely to click "follow." Views and followers are two different metrics; you should identify what content truly brings followers instead of focusing solely on views
 
Yes, I have noticed that to Instagram now focuses on recommending content more than accounts.
 
This have been happening for quite a while now, but, tbh, it don't matter that much, because even if the user just like or interact in your content in anyway, it'll eventually keep appearing to him. Sometimes is even better than begin following, because ig don't show your content to all your followers since a while
 
Reach is decent, but turning that exposure into consistent follower growth is the real challenge now.
 
Growth Navigator said:
Some of my reels are getting decent reach and views but the number of new followers coming from the reach is very lower. A video performs well, get likes and shares but no new followers.

Previously, a reel with similar performance would result in the increase of new followers.

Has anyone else noticed this recently ? What do you think causing it ?
Click to expand...
The new algorithm pushes broad reach but drops conversion, so you must add a strong Call to Action at the end and optimize your Bio to convert casual viewers into followers.
 
Sometimes the photos I post attract a lot of attention and achieve great reach, even though my Instagram account has relatively few followers.
 
migofi said:
Yes, this is something that I have observed too. It is not necessary that reach converts to followers because most of the people view the reels and do not check out the profile anymore. Mostly the thing that makes the difference is having a theme in the profile and giving reasons to follow.
Click to expand...
I have observed this trend too, especially when a reel is promoted far away from its usual target audience on the account. Even though the metrics might seem impressive, the follow ratio lowers bcz of users enjoy the single Reel without seeing any reason to view the account. i becames more interested in tracking the number of profile visits and follows per visit rather than focusing only on reach for the Reel.
 
the fix is making the content more profile-driven (clear niche + stronger CTA like “follow for part x”), not just entertaining.
 
I have noticed something similar lately Views are still coming but converting viewers into followers seems harder than it used to be
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top