Creative Commons Loophole

[darksideday]

Hi,

I don't know if I stumbled upon a loophole or if it sounds to good to be true (probably is).

Lets say I have Channel 'A' and 'B'

If I was to have a niche like something to do with movie trailer/remixes for example. If I uploaded a video on channel 'A' of a movie trailer under Creative Commons and then it gets flagged up for content id. It still has Creative Commons license though.

If I was then to upload the trailer onto Channel 'B' and dispute the content ID by saying that the video it was re-used from had Creative commons license would that work?

 

[InsiderBusiness]

If the video is genuinely allowed to be used and does indeed have a creative commons license you should be able to challenge it. If you are trying to skirt around the issue by effectively creating a creative commons license on channel A for channel B to use, then no it will not work.

 

[darksideday]

If the video is genuinely allowed to be used and does indeed have a creative commons license you should be able to challenge it. If you are trying to skirt around the issue by effectively creating a creative commons license on channel A for channel B to use, then no it will not work.

Thanks for the reply, the reason I ask is that there is nearly every movie trailer in the 'Creative Commons' search so was wondering if they were doing something similar to this.

 

[Divination]

Hi,

I don't know if I stumbled upon a loophole or if it sounds to good to be true (probably is).

Lets say I have Channel 'A' and 'B'

If I was to have a niche like something to do with movie trailer/remixes for example. If I uploaded a video on channel 'A' of a movie trailer under Creative Commons and then it gets flagged up for content id. It still has Creative Commons license though.

If I was then to upload the trailer onto Channel 'B' and dispute the content ID by saying that the video it was re-used from had Creative commons license would that work?

Disputes are reviewed by the copyright holder not YouTube so no it would not work

 

[Deleted member 657006]

If you saw the size of youtube legal team you wouldnt even try.

But if it all your content , worth a challenge.