Confusion about Keyword Density. Yoast VS Other tools

[bgp90]

I'm really confused about keyword density in articles. I have a website with articles which include keywords. For the Onpage SEO I use Yoast. Yoast shows me that I have a keyword density of 0.4%. According to Yoast this is a little bit too low. When I use other tools, like: http://tools.seobook.com/general/keyword-density/. It shows me that I have a keyword density of 2.94%. This really confuses me.

I'm aware of the fact that Yoast only checks the density from the article, while the other tools checks the keyword density from the whole page.
The keyword exist out of three words, for eg. best shavers 2016.
Article is 1098 words long.




Note that Yoast only reports that the kw is include 4 times and the other tools reports that it is included 11 times. Outside of the article I've used the keyword only 1 time as title and the other time in the url. For testing purposes I even removed the keyword from the meta description!!

I don't understand why Yoast says the kw density is too low and the other tool says that it is too high!! Anybody that can explain to me which one is correct?
PS: I know some people are saying that keyword density doesn't matter at all, however I believe that it is one of the main reasons why my pages are not shown up in the google top 300.

 

[aspirea]

1) I'd ignore Yoast
2) Try SEO Quake for on-page analysis
3) We work on a % of between 3 and 5

 

[SEO FOX]

Try this plugin : https://wordpress.org/plugins/seo-tool-keyword-density-checker/

It's a good one mate

 

[bgp90]

1) I'd ignore Yoast
2) Try SEO Quake for on-page analysis
3) We work on a % of between 3 and 5

Try this plugin : https://wordpress.org/plugins/seo-tool-keyword-density-checker/

It's a good one mate

Thanks for the suggestions. I've tried both, and both show other keyword densities. I've always thought that there was a general rule for measuring keyword density. It looks like every tool has it own formula.

 

[Rachmaninoff]

Yes each tool has its own formula. Yoast is more into the kwd density on the article itself. While SEOQuake calculates the whole page, so let's say if you have keywords on sidebar or anywhere but the article, seoquake will count them into kwd density.

 

[ugjunk]

Every tool acts differently but it's important that you pick the right tool that analysis your entire page and not just article, that even includes your breadcrumbs and footer links. I personally use SEOpressor on all my websites as that works out perfectly fine for my requirements and does the needed job.

 

[Writingman1421]

Wordpress seo best plugin is yoast.

 

[nickcookies]

You can count the density manually, ctrl + F, fill in your main keyword, you will see how many it is on your page. Let said your page has 2000 words and 10 x main keyword. 10/2000 x 100 = 0.5%. Dun rely on seo tools too much, trust yourself.