Help me choose alternative for domain and keyword

[personx910]

So, I have 2 kws that are almos same, just one word is difference,
I also 2 have partial match domains, one is new , one is won on auction and will probably be mine DA 9 year
So I could not choose what to do , make one site with both keywords or 2 different sites for different keywords?
one on new domain and second on aged domain?
What is better you think?

 

[member8200]

Aged domain as an obvious answer. Though your idea of emd sites is so2012, build a brand

 

[personx910]

Aged domain as an obvious answer. Though your idea of emd sites is so2012, build a brand

yes aged is better but I was asking if 2 sites on different keywords in same niche are better or one with both keywords on different pages. and they are not EMD they are partial match, they are more broad then actual keyword.

 

[MarketingFist]

Same opinion here i think aged once is better.

I really tried to read your post above but i cant understand what are you trying to say.

 

[scholasticz]

Build on one and 301 redirect the other while building links on both.

 

[nameless7]

Aged domain is definitely better, it will cost you less effots and time

 

[srb888]

Build two sites and play around both. The net has infinite space so why not use it on both? See which one works, and who knows, may be the new one would prove luckier to you in this case? Keep them going for a month or 6, and a clear pic would immerge out of it. Guess work usually gives no gold to the guesser, I guess! lol

 

[Triplescan]

Chose the older domain but only after you check it up to see if something is wrong with it, no spamming history etc. As for the keywords... you will have to chose one that fits the domain. Also you could start with the new domain also but use another keyword, unrelated to the other one you already used. So now you have 2 websites and you can chose the one that starts off best.