phpbuilt
Account compromised December 2025
- May 16, 2011
- 1,865
- 5,369
I have a question you. Does the over optimization affect the entire site or just the page that's overoptimized? I have one site that won't rank even for it's own title (unless I use quotes) and I haven't been able to figure out why. It's a brand name domain (tried moving to a new domain but same results), roughly 35 pages of unique content, ordered about 10 real guest post links for it.
The only thing I can think of is that I might have overused internal links (although I vary up the internal anchor text too). This is the only site I've built this way and the first time I've encountered this issue (the site was created just to test Leith's style of siloing).
Let me tell you something, its soooooo easy to hit the keyword stuffing filter. Even though I wrote this guide, I can't just write articles and have them 100% escape this overoptimization thing automatically. I write 10 articles and 4 of them won't rank because of overoptimization, so its easy to hit the filter. Its really tough because you try to hit that sweet spot, because you have to mention your keywords and I've been SEO writing for a very long time and inclusion of keywords just comes naturally for me.
The penalty is both page-related and site-related. Its page related in that, as I explained in the guide, you can get your page to rank by changing it and then (if it would otherwise rank at #40, but its not in the top 1000 because of overoptimization) ... after you edit it, it pops back to #40 if you did it right.
But its also sitewide, because pages that rank for their terms give stronger internal backlinking. So whatever pages that #40 ranking page links to will now rank better because its a quality page now. That's why its vital to audit your site and correct these issues, if a page doesn't rank then its dead weight.