mine to bro......
YouTube New Comment System Discussion!
- Thread starter Checkmate
- Start date
Checkmate
BANNED
- Aug 9, 2010
- 1,658
- 687
If you post a generic comment will it pass through fine?
greenmusic
Regular Member
- Dec 15, 2012
- 415
- 175
Mmm. I was worried but now I see its happening to you as well. My comments are not showing. It doesn't matter w.e I write it just doesn't show. For a moment I thought it was my ip.
Checkmate
BANNED
- Aug 9, 2010
- 1,658
- 687
From my testing 1 account can only comment 10 times consecutively, after that comments will not go through.
b1step-ahead
Elite Member
- Nov 15, 2010
- 1,731
- 1,035
This sums up google plus..
[video=youtube_share;LTq8TrA3hb4]http://youtu.be/LTq8TrA3hb4[/video]
[video=youtube_share;LTq8TrA3hb4]http://youtu.be/LTq8TrA3hb4[/video]
This was their way of 'replacing' video responses, which for a video site was an infinitely more useful function...
AeroX
Regular Member
- Oct 31, 2011
- 216
- 40
Honestly I like the new comment system. I can post and make my comments on top with additional effort than before. But the good thing is my top comment stay longer than before and link is now clickable. It also eliminates lot of spammers. We need to take advantage of this now while other spammers are still configuring how it works.
hacko
BANNED
- Feb 3, 2010
- 912
- 977
That goes for all of my accounts and channels, too...
Yes, generic comments go through fine, but everything with a slightly related keyword and .com, dot com, DOTcom, etc doesn't... What type of comments did you post with your test account? I even tried posting a generic comment(since only then they're shown), top ratting it on top and then editing it... It immediately got ghosted after I edited it. I'm not liking this. Yesterday I got only 1/3 of the traffic I got the day before(and that's never happened earlier!) and it's constantly decreasing. I'm up for creating a skype group so that we can figure this out, please PM me if interested.
It's not your IP, but I think that you should have no problems posting comments like "hahahah nice vid"...
Are you sure about this? When is the last time you top rated a comment advertising something? Were you still able to do it today?
Checkmate
BANNED
- Aug 9, 2010
- 1,658
- 687
Actually it's worse IMO. It's just like how it was before minus the top comment portion being separated. If the video you comment on get's a lot of view and comments your comment will get pushed down in 2 mins.
Last edited:
AeroX
Regular Member
- Oct 31, 2011
- 216
- 40
On the first day of the update, i thought this is my end because all my income came from youtube comments. Until I found a way to make my comment on top again. I dont have any problem making my comment on top even on popular videos with millions of views and has new comment every minute. Btw i'm doing it manually. Before my top comments on popular videos only stay for a few hours. Now i can see some of my comments are still on top for 2 days now.
Checkmate
BANNED
- Aug 9, 2010
- 1,658
- 687
On the first day of the update, i thought this is my end because all my income came from youtube comments. Until I found a way to make my comment on top again. I dont have any problem making my comment on top even on popular videos with millions of views and has new comment every minute. Btw i'm doing it manually. Before my top comments on popular videos only stay for a few hours. Now i can see some of my comments are still on top for 2 days now.
I don't understand. As of right now Top Comments are just New Comments you can not rank them. Look at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9bZkp7q19f0 you will see some comments have a lot of legitimate likes but will get pushed down as new comments come in.
As comments come in toggle new comments and top comments and you will see they are pretty much just displaying the same thing.
YouFeelMeDawg?
BANNED
- Aug 10, 2011
- 266
- 377
On the first day of the update, i thought this is my end because all my income came from youtube comments. Until I found a way to make my comment on top again. I dont have any problem making my comment on top even on popular videos with millions of views and has new comment every minute. Btw i'm doing it manually. Before my top comments on popular videos only stay for a few hours. Now i can see some of my comments are still on top for 2 days now.
Yea yea yea ... stfu. Everybody who has a brain knows what you up too, just check your post history (You always figure everything out, everything is working for you). Man , get out of here with your self promotion shit, we all know that you sell bots via pm, or skype. You have no shame really, i mean atleast create a new bhw account if you are gonna be pulling that shit here.
greenmusic
Regular Member
- Dec 15, 2012
- 415
- 175
I thought "top comments" were not longer showing as top comments.. You're probably on top cause you were the last person who posted on those video. I might be wrong though.
On the first day of the update, i thought this is my end because all my income came from youtube comments. Until I found a way to make my comment on top again. I dont have any problem making my comment on top even on popular videos with millions of views and has new comment every minute. Btw i'm doing it manually. Before my top comments on popular videos only stay for a few hours. Now i can see some of my comments are still on top for 2 days now.
greenmusic
Regular Member
- Dec 15, 2012
- 415
- 175
lol I knew he was up to no good. lol Saying that can get top comments when there isn't top comments at least for now.
Checkmate
BANNED
- Aug 9, 2010
- 1,658
- 687
hacko
BANNED
- Feb 3, 2010
- 912
- 977
Ugh, things are looking pretty bad guys, they seem to be fixing a lot of glitches right now... Anyway, me and http://www.blackhatworld.com/blackhat-seo/members/1153-hazedoutdesi.html were skyping and I think we're slowly on our way to figuring things out, so if you think you can contribute, again, PM me your skype so that we can work on this together.
greenmusic
Regular Member
- Dec 15, 2012
- 415
- 175
Yep. I'm not even getting 1/2 of the traffic I was getting 3 days ago. At first when the update came out I was killing it, but not anymore. Like Checkmate said, we can only post like 10 comments with one account after that the comments don't even show up. I hate having to log in and out, BUT it is what it is. I'm used to do all the work manually, and it is really complicated right now.