my bh sites are all still on top 5 positions...
changes were +-1...
including the sape sites...
white hat sites were affected which is a test site...
Yup, all my blackhat sites are stronger then ever, gaining ranking for more of my long tail keywords too, sitting in #1 for all my main keywords. Anything with spam essentially. Sape's up top too.
My white-hat sites... lmfao, fell off the charts or below 100. Google should promote this new guy that came up with the concept for this.

Noticed in other niches a bunch of keyword stuffed, purely blackhat garbage sitting in top spots or flooding the first page.
Apparently anything with focused tier 1's gets penalized?
So the moral of the story. more turn and burn pages that you blast with scrapebox and limited keyword lists. But that's just speculation, so don't take my word for it.
What it seems to be (to me) is that with all the recent updates over the past year or two, google has been trying to fight black-hat with the keyword diversification, naked and generic ratios, etc. And what they've realized is that when they change the algo, we adapt in the most 'logical' way to try and overcome, so they're probably trying to think outside of the box and be 'irrational' in the eyes of the blackhat world. So that when we try to get a foot in the door on this latest one, we'll try and fail so miserably because we continue to move forward in the most linear way that we're all used to.
To be honest, who really knows? Only the adderall addicted programmers at google.
Every update for the past year or so, i've watched my sites completely drop off like all of yours, not just drop a few ranks. but completely fall out, thinking I was sandboxed, etc. A few weeks later, I watch it return back to somewhere on page one or two... I spend a few weeks reading, and I figure it out with the rest of you guys. Fairly simple.
Let google release their live bullshit and adapt your methods. Early indications point to them focusing on anything that's linear in regards to your top tiers, etc.
do your keyword research on the top sites and figure out what they're doing. Revert your methods back to pre-penguin bullshit if you have to, because that's what it's starting to look like. Anyone with a keyword profile with a ton of 'click here's' and junk anchor keyword lists might be penalized because they KNOW that, that's what we were using to overcome their last algo's.
Think about it, what can they really do that they haven't already done without chopping off an entire limb to save the infection that's spreading on their body? (black hat seo's are the infection to them.)
So, they're pretty much just hacking away with a rusty jig saw. Spraying antiseptic on it.
Take a look at multiple niches and find out if the keyword profiles for the top few sites contain a number of click here anchors, naked anchors, etc.
They've probably just narrowed the % that's acceptable, because people were going overboard and spamming a larger amount then what looks natural on a real website.
Anyways, HI MATT CUTTS and your team. I know you're reading.

What a beautiful place to have your voice heard by the google webspam team. They won't respond or even bother reading your messages on their webmasters tools, but if you post a tangent here. You're more then going to be seen by them.
I love you! Maybe give me a job working for you guys once all my sites stop making money? Kthnxbye.