Unsuccessful @ Manual Blog Commenting :(

[MarkWW]

People, I am doing manual blog commenting this way:

- Comment is great (I believe), I write it after fully understanding the article and reading previous comments.
- I write My name@My keyword.
- I write my e-mail.
- I write the URL of my website (not domain, subpage like domain.com/i-hate-matt-cutts).
- The IP I am commenting with is not blacklisted anywhere.

But the blog comment never gets approved, I see other people made comments after me and they were approved, even though their comments are stupid. Two things I suspect:

1- When I submit my comment, I never get any kind of confirmation message, I don't know if this is normal. All blogs I am attempting on have KeywordLuv. Am I suppose to get a confirmation message?
2- My comments don't get approved because of using subpage and not domain only. In this case, what would be the solution?

 

[rpkrocks]

1.don't use same anchor text and almost nowhere the one you wanna rank for.
2.say that you have tweeted their post [make a twitter account and tweet there post in real]

 

[MarkWW]

Second point makes sense,
But for first one, use only my name for example? Mark, instead of Dog training?

 

[0_00_0]

Second point makes sense,
But for first one, use only my name for example? Mark, instead of Dog training?

Yes use actual names for blog commenting. Google's new algorithm will destroy you if you use the same anchor text too much.

 

[rpkrocks]

Yes use actual names for blog commenting. Google's new algorithm will destroy you if you use the same anchor text too much.

True,After Penguin i have barely seen sites ranking in kw which were targeted by them in Blog commenting.

 

[MarkWW]

That is right. As for the long URL, should I use a URL shortener? does that pass link juice?

 

[jiksaw213]

that's odd, I sometimes got disapproved, but not really much. I think you should try focusing on the blog that are well taken care, where the blog owner post new articles reply to the readers' comments regularly, and comment on the new posts.

 

[milian]

People, I am doing manual blog commenting this way:


- The IP I am commenting with is not blacklisted anywhere.

Spam blocks work on ip adresss you are posting from, IP address of your site and your email address. So maybe you have been blacklisted on the last two.

If you do a google search you should be able to find sites where you can check if your site IP and your email adress have been blacklisted.

 

[upl8t]

Try doing a manual post through a fresh or private proxy and see if that works.

 

[AQGrimm]

Make sure you are targeting blogs that are active. It might be that the Blog owners aren't active.

 

[markhenry121]

OK!! I will recommend you , you will try to post comment recently post that's quick accepted that's is good for you...for confirmation message point so some blog admin approved you comment but it's lock reply option that's reason you not getting reply message . If you want check your comment approved status, you may be create excel sheet and cross check.

 

[bulletservice]

I agree with the MarkWW's statement. You can use your actual name instead of keywords.

 

[commenting shop]

I am also running an Blog commenitng service and my all comments will approved. You use only ******** Auto Approve blogs for commenting then comment on your comment will be direct appear on the screen not gone in moderator!

 

[jb2008]

Hey commenting shop, if your links are so great why don't you keep them to yourself and use them on your own sites to make money?

Manual comments, I would rather work in the liquor store like that fat guy in Superbad, than do that.....

 

[MarkWW]

Well yes, my website is blacklisted by only one provider and thats APEWS, but these people possibly blacklisted every single IP in the world. The way I am tracking if the comments were approved is by visiting the page itself, yes I see some stupid comments like (how is everyone on this blog? Great Article!) posted after the date of my submission.

Must be my long URL, or my keyword. Will do some experiments and see which one is causing this problem

 

[milian]

Well yes, my website is blacklisted by only one provider and thats APEWS, but these people possibly blacklisted every single IP in the world. The way I am tracking if the comments were approved is by visiting the page itself, yes I see some stupid comments like (how is everyone on this blog? Great Article!) posted after the date of my submission.

Must be my long URL, or my keyword. Will do some experiments and see which one is causing this problem

Do you have a blog yourself with spam protection? Try and post a comment on your own blog and see what happens. You email address might be bloked

 

[ComputerEngineer]

links are getting blocked. you need to use another link. also nowadays i believe comments has 0 value.

 

[The SEO]

The solution is just 1...Use auto approved blog list and forget all the tension occur by those blogs which you have yet.

 

[Bupler]

Well yes, my website is blacklisted by only one provider and thats APEWS, but these people possibly blacklisted every single IP in the world. The way I am tracking if the comments were approved is by visiting the page itself, yes I see some stupid comments like (how is everyone on this blog? Great Article!) posted after the date of my submission.

Must be my long URL, or my keyword. Will do some experiments and see which one is causing this problem

Have any results yet?

 

[masush300]

my 80% sucess
PRocess

Write good sexy GIRLS name ,donot use keyword
Put that girl name related email ,this is good and working
put ur site link
at comment place ,donot make another ahref or link ,its not good
in comment try to read some blog content and ask question rather than telling ,wow ur blog is good ,
use good proxies
Donot use AA list , remember quality is better than quantity ,
scrape good high pr list and try reading and doing manually ,

AA is good too ,AA are low quality traffic caz ,AA blogs are mostly spamed by many people ,so OBL is poor ,,many more..

I recommend my process ,caz i have got sucess ,caz its good ,