Did Google change comment rating security?

[Coron]

Hey BHW,

A week ago I could make my bots thumbs up my comment and it would appear to be the best rated comment to everybody. Now it doesn't work and I don't get it. Even if I rate a comment that isn't mine, the likes show up but it doesn't get set as the top rated. My bots use unique proxies and they send the same data as a non-bot. Has Google changed anything and does anybody know what they changed?

Edit: I thought my accounts were flagged, so I created some fresh accounts and it still did not work.

Thanks.

 

[Ranger11]

They changed some post data on the login not too long ago, I haven't noticed any changes in comment rating though mine still works fine.

 

[Coron]

They changed some post data on the login not too long ago, I haven't noticed any changes in comment rating though mine still works fine.

Have you checked yours from another IP? I think I got my bot working, need to do some further testing.

 

[seotrabajo]

I have the same Problem.. my comments get 50 thumbs up and the comments on the Top only have like 10 thumbs but still my comment dosent go up..

- Coron

Could u tell me how u fix it? I have try all.. Fresh Accounts etc.. nothing works..


I would pay 100$ to the guy who can tell me what youtube changes and how to get them top now .. 3-4 days ago all was working fine...

 

[seotrabajo]

I have try anything.. new accounts, old accounts, new comments, old comments, different proxys.. no way.. i get thumbs up but i dont get in the top..

 

[39ster]

Don't mix new accounts with old proxies and vice versa. If you get new accounts, don't use them until you get new proxies. If you get new proxies, don't use them until you get new accounts.

 

[seotrabajo]

Don't mix new accounts with old proxies and vice versa. If you get new accounts, don't use them until you get new proxies. If you get new proxies, don't use them until you get new accounts.

I have 10k Fresh Proxys every 10 min.. Botnet.. Dosent work with new accs..

 

[Coron]

Don't mix new accounts with old proxies and vice versa. If you get new accounts, don't use them until you get new proxies. If you get new proxies, don't use them until you get new accounts.

I guess the problem is that I use public proxies then. Sometimes they're up, sometimes they're down, so I currently can't bind them to a single account. Do you know a good place to get reliable, private proxies? (I am of course willing to pay)

I have tried some different methods. I can get another comment #1 or #2, but I can rarely get my own to the top. Is it possible that they have flagged a keyword in my comments? (I have tried different account with different IPs)

 

[seotrabajo]

I am using private proxys and new accounts, dosent work to

 

[Coron]

I am using private proxys and new accounts, dosent work to

But do you attach every account to a single account so they don't mix up?
Their new algorithm might be more complicated than we think it is

 

[Ranger11]

Why do you keep trying to change proxies and accounts? If fresh IP's and accounts don't work, It's obviously your bot not doing what youtube wants you to do.

 

[Coron]

Why do you keep trying to change proxies and accounts? If fresh IP's and accounts don't work, It's obviously your bot not doing what youtube wants you to do.

As I said previously I got it working, but the method is rather complicated. I just want to hear if anybody knows what's going on.

 

[seotrabajo]

As I said previously I got it working, but the method is rather complicated. I just want to hear if anybody knows what's going on.

And how u got it working? Why we should tell u how we make it, if u dont tell us how u got it working?

 

[mic22]

Try to make vote looks more organic. I mean go to target video form search results or suggestion list, then vote up some random comments first. It'll be fine if bot could handle flash and javascript to let Google track your steps.

 

[Boom2]

true goodf thread

 

[Coron]

And how u got it working? Why we should tell u how we make it, if u dont tell us how u got it working?

It would literally be against the bhw rules if I told you.
Apparently they also added a 'botguard'. Going to see if I can bypass this.

Try to make vote looks more organic. I mean go to target video form search results or suggestion list, then vote up some random comments first. It'll be fine if bot could handle flash and javascript to let Google track your steps.

Yes, I'm guessing that's what they do. Who knows, perhaps time is involved, as it would be unhuman to login and rate a comment all under two seconds.

 

[izSpK]

Did they add botguard on YouTube requests? I am too lazy to check lol.

Last time I checked it was for account registration only.

 

[Saint-Hero]

I Still can make top comments but manually,no bots, I'm doing around 20 comments every day.

 

[Coron]

Did they add botguard on YouTube requests? I am too lazy to check lol.

Last time I checked it was for account registration only.

Nope, as far as I know all ajax requests are untouched (as of now). Also, I discovered that the botguard doesn't support old browsers (Mozilla 4.0 is unsupported) - but then it requires you to verify your account.

 

[Germs]

Using 30 accounts with 1 private proxy each, i can no longer get top rated comment using youtube genius