- Mar 31, 2025
- 256
- 141
Not another “SEO is dead” thread, lol
But I do think the shape of SEO is changing fast with AI search, ChatGPT-style engines, AI Overviews, etc. I wanted to throw my 3 big beliefs on the table and see where you all agree / disagree / think I’m full of it.
I’m genuinely curious what other people here are seeing in their niches.
1) SEO becomes “Search Everywhere Optimization”, not just Google
I don’t think “SEO = Google only” is true anymore because it's happening:
The question in my head is shifting from:
to:
What I’m doing because of this:
2) Content becomes data[, not just “blog posts”
I don’t think the big AI systems care that much about “another 2,000-word article.”
They care about:
So I’m shifting away from:
and more toward:
Things I’m doing differently:
If it’s just another generic blog with fluff… I think that’s what gets replaced first.
What do you think? Overkill, or is this where things are heading?
3) The big strategic shift: from “rankings” to a discovery portfolio
This is probably my spiciest take:
The KPI in my head is no longer:
It’s more like:
That leads to a different game:
Rankings still matter, obviously. I’m not pretending they don’t.
But if AI Overviews, ChatGPT search, etc. keep growing… then pure “I’m #1 in blue links” feels like only one slice of a bigger discovery portfolio.
What do you guys think? Let's discuss together
But I do think the shape of SEO is changing fast with AI search, ChatGPT-style engines, AI Overviews, etc. I wanted to throw my 3 big beliefs on the table and see where you all agree / disagree / think I’m full of it.
I’m genuinely curious what other people here are seeing in their niches.
1) SEO becomes “Search Everywhere Optimization”, not just Google
I don’t think “SEO = Google only” is true anymore because it's happening:
- Classic Google organic + AI Overviews / AI answers
- ChatGPT-style search / assistants
- Gemini, Perplexity, Bing, etc.
- And then social search (TikTok, YouTube, Reddit) on top of it
The question in my head is shifting from:
“How do I rank #1 on Google?”
to:
“If someone (or some AI assistant) asks a question in my niche… does that system even know I exist and why I’m credible?”
What I’m doing because of this:
- Treating AI assistants as actual traffic channels, not “oh cool, some random referral.”
- Making pages more machine-readable: clear headings, lists, tables, internal anchors, simple intros that explain what the page is and who it’s for.
- Watching traffic from chatgpt, perplexity, etc. as a separate “AI discovery” channel in my tracking.
2) Content becomes data[, not just “blog posts”
I don’t think the big AI systems care that much about “another 2,000-word article.”
They care about:
- Tables
- Comparisons
- FAQs
- Checklists
- Clear definitions
- Simple, quotable explanations
So I’m shifting away from:
“Let’s crank out another generic long post”
and more toward:
“Let’s publish reusable blocks of knowledge that humans and AIs can both plug into.”
Things I’m doing differently:
- Turning key insights into tables / matrices instead of hiding them in walls of text.
- Adding FAQ blocks that directly match what people (and AI) ask.
- Making sure every important concept has a clean 1–3 sentence explanation that an AI could lift without confusion.
If it’s just another generic blog with fluff… I think that’s what gets replaced first.
What do you think? Overkill, or is this where things are heading?
3) The big strategic shift: from “rankings” to a discovery portfolio
This is probably my spiciest take:
The KPI in my head is no longer:
“Am I #1 for this one keyword?”
It’s more like:
“Across all search & AI surfaces, do I own enough high-intent discovery moments with content/tools that are worth citing and sending traffic to?”
That leads to a different game:
- Mapping topics by intention + money value, not just search volume
- Redesigning core money pages into structured resources instead of generic “SEO articles”
- Investing in flagship assets (tools, comparison engines, stats pages, datasets, strong guides) that search engines and AI systems actually want to show
Rankings still matter, obviously. I’m not pretending they don’t.
But if AI Overviews, ChatGPT search, etc. keep growing… then pure “I’m #1 in blue links” feels like only one slice of a bigger discovery portfolio.
What do you guys think? Let's discuss together