Did We All Become NPCs With Dashboards and $17 Courses?

EngagementPlug

Regular Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2025
Messages
262
Reaction score
463
Not gonna lie… every time I open BHW lately, it feels like déjà vu:
“How I made $13.24 in 48 hours using this insane method”
“Just bought a $9.99 ebook, gonna document my journey to 6 figures”
“Need help with automation, but I don’t wanna pay”
Where’s the digital witchcraft?
Where are the OGs who used to run custom JavaScript cloaking at 3AM, downing a Monster and dodging Google bans like it was ritual warfare?

Now it’s like everyone’s selling the same recycled info, learning the same funnels, regurgitating the same ChatGPT prompts.
And the guys claiming $10K/month… why do they always have time to post 40 times a day?

Have we all become NPCs in a dropshipping simulator with a “side hustle” skin?

I miss the chaos. The edge. The hunger.
Now it’s all dashboards, KPIs, and Canva-made dreams.

But hey, maybe it’s just me.
 
It is definitely dead scene. Everyone are selling garbage services, PBN, tutorials, books.
 
Is it just me or is this post a chatgpt post lmao. I use it way too much to know the patterns of texts

But to answer it anyway, this forum never really got too into black hat stuff. In the 5 years I’ve been signed up anyway, I’ve only encountered the same old methods and maybe 1-2 truly black hat scaling
 
Is it just me or is this post a chatgpt post lmao. I use it way too much to know the patterns of texts

But to answer it anyway, this forum never really got too into black hat stuff. In the 5 years I’ve been signed up anyway, I’ve only encountered the same old methods and maybe 1-2 truly black hat scaling
Yeah, forum is older than 5 years
 
Yeah, forum is older than 5 years
I know that, just mentioned in the 5 years of me joining and being active. I used to casually visit for years before that but even then I’ve never seen anything too black hat. I remember affiliate white hat stuff being a big thing for years
 
I know that, just mentioned in the 5 years of me joining and being active. I used to casually visit for years before that but even then I’ve never seen anything too black hat. I remember affiliate white hat stuff being a big thing for years
Yeah, I'll be honest with you - wh businesses from my country are more blackhat than this (and technically these aren't criminals or even grayhat, completely whitehat niches).
 
I totally get where you're coming from. It feels like the hustle has shifted from raw, creative problem-solving to just following formulas and funnels. The old-school chaos and ingenuity seem to have been replaced with cookie-cutter strategies and dashboard obsession. That said, there are still folks out there running wild, experimenting, and pushing the boundaries, but they're harder to find. The key is to stay true to your own process and not get caught in the echo chamber of recycled content.
It is definitely dead scene. Everyone are selling garbage services, PBN, tutorials, books.
Exactly. It’s like we went from pirates to PowerPoint presentations.
The wild, experimental energy got replaced by dashboards and checklists. Everyone’s just repackaging garbage services, fake PBNs, outdated tutorials, low-effort ebooks… selling to each other in an endless circle jerk.

The few real hustlers left? Silent. In the shadows. Printing quietly while the NPC crowd screams “free method pls.
Feels like 99% of the scene is just monetizing the dream instead of the hustle.
Sometimes I wonder… maybe the real money was in teaching others how to make money all along.

Is it just me or is this post a chatgpt post lmao. I use it way too much to know the patterns of texts

But to answer it anyway, this forum never really got too into black hat stuff. In the 5 years I’ve been signed up anyway, I’ve only encountered the same old methods and maybe 1-2 truly black hat scaling
Haha busted :D , honestly, you’re not wrong. My GPT usage is showing like a bad spray tan. But hey, at least it wasn’t one of those “here’s my affiliate link disguised as wisdom” posts.

And yeah, totally agree. BHW’s always had this weird split: marketed as “black hat” but most of the activity has been grey hat or even white hat with a sketchy wrapper. Actual black hat ops? 0.01% and usually off-forum or in super-private circles.

Maybe we’re just too old for this “buy my Canva-made funnel” era

Yeah, forum is older than 5 years
Yeah, true, it’s way older. But feels like the last real black hat waves dried up even longer ago. Now it’s mostly “black hat” in name only, like a nostalgia brand for chaos that doesn’t really exist anymore :D

Still hoping some actual wild experiments pop up once in a while though.

I know that, just mentioned in the 5 years of me joining and being active. I used to casually visit for years before that but even then I’ve never seen anything too black hat. I remember affiliate white hat stuff being a big thing for years
Makes sense. Honestly, kinda wild how “black hat” turned into a branding term more than an actual practice on here. Feels like the really dirty tricks have either gone completely private… or just died off with platforms getting tighter.

Affiliate white hat definitely dominated for years. Now it’s like… a sea of cookie-cutter templates, expired methods, and people selling courses on how to sell courses :D
Sometimes I wonder if actual black hat never left… we just stopped being invited to the right tables.

Yeah, I'll be honest with you - wh businesses from my country are more blackhat than this (and technically these aren't criminals or even grayhat, completely whitehat niches).

Exactly :D some “totally legit” white hat businesses out there running ops dirtier than anything I’ve ever seen on here. Kinda crazy when you realize half the corporate world is just black hat with better lawyers.

Meanwhile BHW’s stuck debating $5 logo arbitrage and expired domain scraping like it’s the bleeding edge.
Makes you wonder who’s really playing the game.

that is not true :)
there was a ton of magical shit before your time
that's all I am allowed to say

Lmao now you’re just teasing us like it’s some secret society :D
Drop a hint at least… or is there a blood pact involved?
 
Between 2008-2016, this place was on fire with methods. It's just how the state of the internet was.

People doing YouTube and social media like it is today wasn't that prevalent. That time period is just gone.
 
Those that have been around for a while know that sharing is the quicks way to kill something.

So the best stuff is kept secret.

Even if you share it with just 1 close person on here, they might share it with their "best friend" or "cousin" and the method will die soon after.

The magic is there, but you gotta earn your way to that magical kingdom by being a mad hatter experimenting and figuring shit out on your own, or by providing insane value and being invited into the best inner circles.
 
that is not true :)
there was a ton of magical shit before your time
that's all I am allowed to say
Agreed.

Between 2008-2016, this place was on fire with methods. It's just how the state of the internet was.

People doing YouTube and social media like it is today wasn't that prevalent. That time period is just gone.
Days when social media and other platforms weren't so strict. And even when they were on the merge to becoming strict, methods after methods emerged.
 
Between 2008-2016, this place was on fire with methods. It's just how the state of the internet was.

People doing YouTube and social media like it is today wasn't that prevalent. That time period is just gone.
Facts. That era was wild, felt like everyone was figuring out the rules as they broke them. Whole internet was the wild west back then.

Now it’s like… sanitized platforms, algorithm babysitters, and everyone selling the same “secrets” that don’t work anymore :D
Can’t replicate that chaos. Different world.

Those that have been around for a while know that sharing is the quicks way to kill something.

So the best stuff is kept secret.

Even if you share it with just 1 close person on here, they might share it with their "best friend" or "cousin" and the method will die soon after.

The magic is there, but you gotta earn your way to that magical kingdom by being a mad hatter experimenting and figuring shit out on your own, or by providing insane value and being invited into the best inner circles.
Couldn’t have said it better.
The real magic’s always been a currency, it doesn’t get posted, it gets earned. And yeah, most methods don’t die from saturation, they die from being shared with the wrong pair of lips.

At the end of the day, you either build your own key… or get trusted enough to be handed one.
Respect to those still wearing the mad hat

The old tricks are gone on BHW; to stand out again, we need to get back to our own midnight hacks.
Exactly. No more copy-paste “hustles”, time to get back to breaking shit at 2AM, testing weird ideas, writing scripts nobody else would dare run.

That’s where the next wave’s gonna come from. Not from threads… but from the labs nobody sees.
Let’s bring the chaos back.

Agreed.


Days when social media and other platforms weren't so strict. And even when they were on the merge to becoming strict, methods after methods emerged.
100%. It was a beautiful cycle, platforms tried to tighten the walls, and every time they did, someone found a crack and turned it into a floodgate.

Now it feels like the walls are taller, the cracks smaller… but they’re still there. Just takes sharper eyes and riskier moves.
The game never stopped. It just went deeper underground.

my ass is on the line
gotta be there to experience it
Fair enough :D gotta respect the code.
Sounds like one of those “if you know, you know” rites of passage… guess I’ll have to earn my seat at the table the hard way.


Respect, OG.
 
More than 10 years ago. A BHW member and I were banking from a method. We made some very good money and optimizing it everyday. We were on skype everyday. It was insane.
One day he decided without telling me to share it on BHW for likes. In less than a month, the method was dead. Too many people were using it. It was saturated.

Back in the day, google, youtube, social networks were less strict and had less security/update. You could find method every day. These days are over.

Years ago, you could make money with just a blogspot blog or one Facebook account. Now you need more assets. Proxies, open ai, domain name, hosting, 100 social network accounts, expensive backlinks,expensive softwares, custome made softwares.

Now you need money to make money.

In my opinion, now you either go full white hat or you automate everything with the help of AI.

If you find a good untapped method you keep it to yourself.
 
Many online platforms now promote dashboard-style thinking and monetized advice, so it is reasonable to be concerned. Some courses are beneficial, but it is best to maintain your critical thinking. Not all people who charge $17 for a course are truly knowledgeable. Avoid becoming unduly dependent on flimsy metrics or prepackaged solutions, and strike a balance between learning and independent thought.
 
Nah, it’s not just you. The raw, rogue spirit’s been sanitized. Hustle turned hobby. Edge got optimized. Chaos became content.
 
Yeah in the beginning I was eating up all the courses I could get my hands on, I mostly went a looong way to avoid paying for it full price, glad I did, most of them are literally worthless, best teacher is experience and trying.
 
You better keep it to yourself, punk. Or else...
Lmao :D respect, respect.
No worries, he’s taking it to the grave… or at least till the next Google update.

More than 10 years ago. A BHW member and I were banking from a method. We made some very good money and optimizing it everyday. We were on skype everyday. It was insane.
One day he decided without telling me to share it on BHW for likes. In less than a month, the method was dead. Too many people were using it. It was saturated.

Back in the day, google, youtube, social networks were less strict and had less security/update. You could find method every day. These days are over.

Years ago, you could make money with just a blogspot blog or one Facebook account. Now you need more assets. Proxies, open ai, domain name, hosting, 100 social network accounts, expensive backlinks,expensive softwares, custome made softwares.

Now you need money to make money.

In my opinion, now you either go full white hat or you automate everything with the help of AI.

If you find a good untapped method you keep it to yourself.
Damn, that’s rough. Crazy how something that took time to build can die overnight just because it got shared. Seen it happen too many times.
And yeah, it’s true… back then you could get away with so much using the simplest setups. Now it feels like you need a full tech stack just to stay afloat. AI, proxies, accounts, infrastructure… it’s a different game.

These days, if you find something that works, best to keep it quiet and milk it solo. Sharing is how you kill it.
Respect for still being here after all these years.

Many online platforms now promote dashboard-style thinking and monetized advice, so it is reasonable to be concerned. Some courses are beneficial, but it is best to maintain your critical thinking. Not all people who charge $17 for a course are truly knowledgeable. Avoid becoming unduly dependent on flimsy metrics or prepackaged solutions, and strike a balance between learning and independent thought.
Yeah, totally agree with that. Nothing wrong with learning from others, but you gotta filter the noise and not just blindly follow whatever’s packaged in a nice dashboard or cheap course.

At the end of the day, real wins come from experimenting, not copying. Gotta keep that critical mindset or you end up just another number in someone else’s funnel.

Nah, it’s not just you. The raw, rogue spirit’s been sanitized. Hustle turned hobby. Edge got optimized. Chaos became content.
Perfect way to put it. The game didn’t die, it just got domesticated.
But some of us still miss the wild.

Yeah in the beginning I was eating up all the courses I could get my hands on, I mostly went a looong way to avoid paying for it full price, glad I did, most of them are literally worthless, best teacher is experience and trying.
Facts. I did the same, hoarded courses like they were gold, then realized most were just common sense wrapped in slides :D
At the end of the day, nothing beats getting your hands dirty and figuring shit out yourself. That’s where the real lessons are.
 
Back
Top