Importance of domain name?

[TurboCharge]

Does someone know if the domain name can have such a significant impact on CTR and UX, that it makes SEO for that website almost impossible? I'm talking naming a cooking blog "Michael.com" instead of something cooking related.

I've struggled with a website for five years and the only weakness it has now that I can see is the domain name. It's in the finance niche and its name is something like "Spaceship.com", with the early brand idea that we would "accelerate finance". We've recently abandoned that idea altogether, and I realize we probably needed to build brand awareness to even establish that connection to begin with. User searches → Sees results like Finances.com (Find the best credit cards 2025), Forbes.com (Your guide to better finances), MyMoney.com (Improve your finances today), Spaceship.com (Find the best credit cards now). The last result doesn't incite clicks because the domain name doesn't say anything, but I never thought this could cripple a website's SEO. I thought you could still build SEO, and when "Spaceship.com" became the top result, people would naturally be interested to see why.

But question, does someone know if a semi-irrelevant domain name like this can have such a big impact on SEO it's crippling? As I've been thinking about this, I've considered other cases of "irrelevant domain names" but each of those still conveyed some message. One is called something like "Better.co.uk", and they have strong advertising on TV. People click because it's "Better.com", and they get a sense of "bettering their finances". For my case, there is 0 brand awareness, we rely on SEO, and the domain name doesn't say anything. Assumed we'd do SEO first and brand awareness would come later.

But thus, can a semi-irrelevant domain name like this be crippling for SEO? Are there cases where SEO's been fixed after a domain name change?

 

[xReminisce]

Honesty i feel like It's a presentation nowadays.
You don't need the most fancy, but it has to be presentable.
aoifjaisfja.com will work just fine if you put your back in it but people gonna raise a eyebrow when looking at your domain name

 

[TurboCharge]

Honesty i feel like It's a presentation nowadays.
You don't need the most fancy, but it has to be presentable.
aoifjaisfja.com will work just fine if you put your back in it but people gonna raise a eyebrow when looking at your domain name

I wonder does Google care though or is it entirely user based? Let's say you do aoifjaisfja.com and you get 0,8% CTR. Would Google prefer other sites over yours because the name provides a bad user experience (or trust?) or would it be based entirely on user signals (CTR)?

I've ranked websites with 0,3% CTR well and my current, which has 0,7% (1,3% before a few updates ago) barely ranks at all. Granted, it is in a YMYL niche, but the question still stands.

 

[TurboCharge]

ChatGPT is the biggest gaslighter of all time. Asking it for reasons why "Spaceship.com" isn't ranking and it gives me new reasons every day. It confirmed this theory and then backtracked when I showed a bounce rate of 48%.

It truly boggles my mind why this website is held back to this degree. I am going to change domain names tomorrow. I think the current name might have a negative connotation and be what's holding the website back. The new name I've came up with immediately says what the website offers, which might build more trust with the user and lead to better user signals. I am so mind boggled and drained, as well as emotionally attached to this name, I don't know what to do. Five years of daily struggle.

 

[sjmasku]

Domain name will always influence SEO. If you can't secure an exact match domain for your niche, consider a domain with similar characteristics to an EMD, but one that leans more towards a branded domain. Also, it's important to keep your site updated. Google values fresh, relevant content, so consistently publishing new content is essential for maintaining strong search engine rankings.

 

[BigAda l]

A partial keyword domain still works for local SEO - big time.

 

[xReminisce]

I wonder does Google care though or is it entirely user based? Let's say you do aoifjaisfja.com and you get 0,8% CTR. Would Google prefer other sites over yours because the name provides a bad user experience (or trust?) or would it be based entirely on user signals (CTR)?

I've ranked websites with 0,3% CTR well and my current, which has 0,7% (1,3% before a few updates ago) barely ranks at all. Granted, it is in a YMYL niche, but the question still stands.

It would be much more user base that cares about a shitty domain then google.
This isn't 2000s anymore

 

[meihualiang]

Hello, I hope my reply can help you solve your problems.

1. Unrelated domain names may harm SEO:
If the domain name is completely unrelated to the content, users and search engines will think it is unprofessional and reduce trust.
But the impact is limited, and content quality and external links are still the core of ranking.

2. SEO can be repaired after changing the domain name:
Through 301 redirection, point the old domain name to the new domain name, and pass more than 90% of the weight.
Submit a new site map, update external links, and usually restore rankings in 36 months.

Key points:
The new domain name must be strongly related to the business;
Keep the old domain name for at least 1 year to avoid traffic cliffs.

 

[syabah]

'Forbes' doesn't actually related to financial world.

 

[TurboCharge]

'Forbes' doesn't actually related to financial world.

No but it has brand recognition. It’s associated with finance now. I’m thinking if no one knew what CNN was, would it rank through pure SEO alone? I wonder if there are case studies on this. I’m trying to find something but can’t find any anything even on BHW after all these years. It feels like someone should have tried something like this, where a domain that simply did not rank despite good content started doing so after the domain was changed to something ”better”. I know there are instances daily where people don’t know why a domain hasn’t ranked for years, but I can’t find anyone who tried changing the domain to something else.

 

[praetserge]

In my view... domain name can't have such an impact. It's the lack of branding which holds it back.
Take amazon, for example, it has nothing to do with the river and yet it ranks just fine, and there are many examples like this one.

 

[MR_SOOMRO]

A semi-irrelevant domain name can impact CTR and brand trust, affecting SEO indirectly. Changing to a relevant, keyword-rich domain may improve click-through rates and overall SEO performance.

 

[TurboCharge]

In my view... domain name can't have such an impact. It's the lack of branding which holds it back.
Take amazon, for example, it has nothing to do with the river and yet it ranks just fine, and there are many examples like this one.

That's what I'm thinking too. CNN, as I mentioned, or Forbes. But how do they determine "brand recognition"? It has to be CTR. But when I look at the CTR of my website – 1,3–0,6% depending on the rank – it doesn't seem to be the reason why it doesn't rank. I am incredibly tempted to change domain names, but the new name has a completely different feel to it.

Currently, I'm migrating the website to a new domain so I will have all the same pages, same everything, except a new domain. I will make the fluff content unique with GPT, fix a new branding, but what the website offers will be exactly the same as the previous website, even in design. So for the user, it will be the same website with a new brand. For Google, it will be a new website with new content.

I will see if this new brand ranks much better than the other. Easiest would of course be to just change the domain immediately. I could do it today and start measuring the impact. Transitioning will take weeks. But this is the safest way I guess.

I can see how a more "relevant" domain name can lead to better UX and Trust, but how the hell can I verify if this is what is holding my website back? "Spaceship.com – Find the best finances". Yeah, the domain is irrelevant, but is it so irrelevant it's affecting its rank?

A semi-irrelevant domain name can impact CTR and brand trust, affecting SEO indirectly. Changing to a relevant, keyword-rich domain may improve click-through rates and overall SEO performance.

Any examples of someone improving their SEO by making such a change?

 

[GenesisOne]

Michaelkitchen.com would work best.

 

[praetserge]

That's what I'm thinking too. CNN, as I mentioned, or Forbes. But how do they determine "brand recognition"? It has to be CTR. But when I look at the CTR of my website – 1,3–0,6% depending on the rank – it doesn't seem to be the reason why it doesn't rank. I am incredibly tempted to change domain names, but the new name has a completely different feel to it.

Currently, I'm migrating the website to a new domain so I will have all the same pages, same everything, except a new domain. I will make the fluff content unique with GPT, fix a new branding, but what the website offers will be exactly the same as the previous website, even in design. So for the user, it will be the same website with a new brand. For Google, it will be a new website with new content.

I will see if this new brand ranks much better than the other. Easiest would of course be to just change the domain immediately. I could do it today and start measuring the impact. Transitioning will take weeks. But this is the safest way I guess.

I can see how a more "relevant" domain name can lead to better UX and Trust, but how the hell can I verify if this is what is holding my website back? "Spaceship.com – Find the best finances". Yeah, the domain is irrelevant, but is it so irrelevant it's affecting its rank?


Any examples of someone improving their SEO by making such a change?

In the UK now, it's normal to see the ads which say something like "search for army jobs" or "on the beach"... needless to say... .uk army site ranks #1 for army and onthebeach.co.uk ranks #1 for "on the beach"... they do it to get branding. They don't say "go to onthebeach.co.uk" but they say search for it... brilliant marketing.

 

[omi3oh1]

If your domain doesn’t match your niche, users might skip (search Traffic) your link, even if you rank well, because it doesn’t feel relevant.

 

[godssolder]

Yes, a domain name can significantly impact your site's SEO performance, particularly through its influence on user behavior and click-through rates (CTR). While Google has stated that domain names are not a direct ranking factor, a domain that clearly reflects your site's content can improve user trust and engagement, indirectly boosting SEO.

In your case, using a domain like "Spaceship.com" for a finance-related site may confuse users, leading to lower CTRs compared to competitors with more relevant domain names. This mismatch can hinder your site's ability to rank well, as search engines consider user engagement metrics when determining rankings.

There are instances where changing to a more relevant domain name has led to improved SEO outcomes. For example, a case study showed that after a domain change, organic search traffic grew by 170% in the first 60 days, and lead generation from search improved by 26%. Reference: https://blacktruckmedia.com/case-studies/seo-implications-for-a-domain-name-change/

However, changing your domain name is a significant decision that requires careful planning to mitigate potential SEO risks. It's essential to implement proper redirects, update all references to the old domain, and monitor your site's performance during the transition.

If you're considering a domain change to better align with your site's content, it could be a worthwhile investment in the long term. Just ensure that you approach the change strategically to preserve and enhance your SEO performance.

 

[TurboCharge]

Yes, a domain name can significantly impact your site's SEO performance, particularly through its influence on user behavior and click-through rates (CTR). While Google has stated that domain names are not a direct ranking factor, a domain that clearly reflects your site's content can improve user trust and engagement, indirectly boosting SEO.

In your case, using a domain like "Spaceship.com" for a finance-related site may confuse users, leading to lower CTRs compared to competitors with more relevant domain names. This mismatch can hinder your site's ability to rank well, as search engines consider user engagement metrics when determining rankings.

There are instances where changing to a more relevant domain name has led to improved SEO outcomes. For example, a case study showed that after a domain change, organic search traffic grew by 170% in the first 60 days, and lead generation from search improved by 26%. Reference: https://blacktruckmedia.com/case-studies/seo-implications-for-a-domain-name-change/

However, changing your domain name is a significant decision that requires careful planning to mitigate potential SEO risks. It's essential to implement proper redirects, update all references to the old domain, and monitor your site's performance during the transition.

If you're considering a domain change to better align with your site's content, it could be a worthwhile investment in the long term. Just ensure that you approach the change strategically to preserve and enhance your SEO performance.

Thanks GPT.

 

[hot2364928]

I haven't seen the exact numbers, but I have a feeling it would be very significant.

 

[Marco69]

Hi today and a wonderful warm weather 1. May to all !

I not understand why short 3,4,5 letter domains abbreviations, not means anything are so expensive on domain market places?
How would you do handle a short domain name- acronym?
Example hwktr.com (Henry Whittacker) is available means nothing for users

how do you brand it on your wordpress site ?
1) use your slogan/ or personal name on the wp cms site title ? like; Henry Whittacker coach or something....
2) use a tagline , but most themes not support it anymore, here is your slogan ?
3) or brand it out on the Home page as H1 title like : Henry Whittacker strategy coach

Would you register; hwktr.com or hwhittacker.com and have your slogan like Whittacker strategy coach in the wordpress cms site title?