Question about scraping PAA

[SharonHe]

When scraping for PAA what is the best question to take it as post title?

Let's say I search for "cat food" and we get PAA box. What is the best question to take as our title?
Is it the first one?

I went by saving them all as separate posts and combining them in relevance but the problem is that there are many posts content dupes that have very slight question difference like "a", "the", "when", "how" etc etc but their anser or body text is the same.

So I am thinking to do only 50ish paa scraps per query and combine them in one post. The problem is what the post title should be.

Thanks

 

[tazarbm]

you can use whichever you like, but I prefer giving it a more general title (for example: Cat Foods - Important Questions, Answered... or Important Cat Food Questions You Might Have... stuff like this), add a few intro paragraphs and a conclusion (20-30 words each), and then insert all of those PAA questions as H2 tags between the intro and conclusion

the problem is that there are many posts content dupes that have very slight question difference like "a", "the", "when", "how" etc etc but their anser or body text is the same.

all of those prefixes mean the same thing and google will treat all of those questions as one (as long as they have the same meaning, obviously). So, use whichever you want as a H2, write 20-30 words for each question and call it a PAA!

So I am thinking to do only 50ish paa scraps per query and combine them in one post.

damn, 50 is a lot! You might scare your visitors away with such a big wall of text on a single page

Just pick 5-10 extremely relevant (to each other) PAAs, group them all in one article, add an intro and conclusion paragraph and call it an article! Or, if you really want to insert them all into one big article at least add a Table of Contents section after the intro paragraph to save your visitors time and scrolling

 

[RealDaddy]

You can use something like - https://searchresponse.io/

I tried their tool and it isn't sending duplicates and the pricing is also pretty affordable (I am not affiliated or associated with the site/tool).

Cc @Holzr (thanks for sharing )

 

[SharonHe]

you can use whichever you like, but I prefer giving it a more general title (for example: Cat Foods - Important Questions, Answered... or Important Cat Food Questions You Might Have... stuff like this), add a few intro paragraphs and a conclusion (20-30 words each), and then insert all of those PAA questions as H2 tags between the intro and conclusion


all of those prefixes mean the same thing and google will treat all of those questions as one (as long as they have the same meaning, obviously). So, use whichever you want as a H2, write 20-30 words for each question and call it a PAA!


damn, 50 is a lot! You might scare your visitors away with such a big wall of text on a single page

Just pick 5-10 extremely relevant (to each other) PAAs, group them all in one article, add an intro and conclusion paragraph and call it an article! Or, if you really want to insert them all into one big article at least add a Table of Contents section after the intro paragraph to save your visitors time and scrolling

I am making auto scraper and poster for Wordpress so this is automate process. that is why I am not able to choose manually.

 

[bloggingguy]

When scraping for PAA what is the best question to take it as post title?

Let's say I search for "cat food" and we get PAA box. What is the best question to take as our title?
Is it the first one?

I went by saving them all as separate posts and combining them in relevance but the problem is that there are many posts content dupes that have very slight question difference like "a", "the", "when", "how" etc etc but their anser or body text is the same.

So I am thinking to do only 50ish paa scraps per query and combine them in one post. The problem is what the post title should be.

Thanks

The title of the 1st post in serp page or the title of the 1st PAA. My AI writer also gives a title when it generates the article from these titles.

 

[SharonHe]

The title of the 1st post in serp page or the title of the 1st PAA. My AI writer also gives a title when it generates the article from these titles.

So your AI writer takes the first PAA?

 

[bloggingguy]

So your AI writer takes the first PAA?

It takes either of 3 titles my software is set to choose one randomly based on some factors like usage of keyword in the titles, the PA of the exact URL, no of words on that page.

 

[Alexion]

The title has to be a question, so the first paragraph answers it. You haven't been paying much attention to the guys doing it.

 

[SharonHe]

It takes either of 3 titles my software is set to choose one randomly based on some factors like usage of keyword in the titles, the PA of the exact URL, no of words on that page.

Exactly what I was thinking, thanks
How many PAAs do you scrape per post? 40? 50?

 

[bloggingguy]

Exactly what I was thinking, thanks
How many PAAs do you scrape per post? 40? 50?

10-15 per post.

 

[nazmulfeni4]

At first try to collect Question by ahref / SEMrush or other tools with search volume, Then collect PAA and publish post

 

[insynch]

The title has to be a question, so the first paragraph answers it.

This. Don't overthink it. Actually title can be any of your questions, usually first one in the batch.

 

[vitle]

you can use whichever you like, but I prefer giving it a more general title (for example: Cat Foods - Important Questions, Answered... or Important Cat Food Questions You Might Have... stuff like this), add a few intro paragraphs and a conclusion (20-30 words each), and then insert all of those PAA questions as H2 tags between the intro and conclusion


all of those prefixes mean the same thing and google will treat all of those questions as one (as long as they have the same meaning, obviously). So, use whichever you want as a H2, write 20-30 words for each question and call it a PAA!


damn, 50 is a lot! You might scare your visitors away with such a big wall of text on a single page

Just pick 5-10 extremely relevant (to each other) PAAs, group them all in one article, add an intro and conclusion paragraph and call it an article! Or, if you really want to insert them all into one big article at least add a Table of Contents section after the intro paragraph to save your visitors time and scrolling

Thanks you!

 

[Kinu Actaz]

At first try to collect Question by ahref / SEMrush or other tools with search volume, Then collect PAA and publish post

How much traffic are you getting with this approach?