Although I suspected you wasted several k $$$ reading your journey as you bought countless useless forum links, pbns et cetera.
You said that you (or a guy who you bought website from) targeted high-comp keywords at the beginning, the articles cover broad niche and are too bad. They are not going to rank anywhere.
What you should do:
- Make a decent structure on your site and put articles in the proper categories. Example: Cars->Audi Cars->Audi Car A, Audi Car B and so on
- Buy Ahrefs ($7 trial for 7 days is enough) or Semrush (30-day trial is cool too). Must have tools
- Check for what keywords you rank, if you are in TOP-10/20 check them, sometimes editing and expanding articles (adding 0-10 relevant keywords) in a proper way helps them to get higher in serps.
- Check competitors, how they write, what they target
- Add articles targeting low competitive keywords for the categories that a) already have articles b) already ranking. In other words expand articles/categories you already getting organic traffic from Google.
Basically you have to rewrite and redo what you have done previously. If you are super serious about this site, order a website audit from some guy, theoretically a good audit will be more beneficial for you than hundreds of links.
And stop buying links before you understand what are good links and what are bad.
If everything done right, you increase your traffic from niches you already cover plus let the big G know that you're up to something else. Maybe reach 1k too. Will make good foundation to expand in the future as you already present in a broad niche.
Cause now it looks like a failed journey, you don't spend 10-15k for 200 bucks a month. With such expenses, 2-3k in revenue you should be your minimum otherwise it's totally useless. But for newbies it's useful case study as it tells them what NOT to do when you start in seo.
Thanks for the feedback.
I will try and respond to everything you said.
To me, a journey thread is my journey. Failing or succeeding. You literally cannot start and be a massive success from the get-go. I chose to invest and see what works and what does not. I literally listed all my mistakes in this thread so others can learn as well.
Here is a list of my expenses for this site.
5k was when I outsourced the start of the site. I spent another 1k or so fixing stuff that got messed up with the site because of the people who were working on the site and a little more than that trying to find a good writer. I used a writing service on here, I will not mention, for close to 1000 bucks and they were completely awful and a waste of time as well.
4k is to my main writer on Upwork and a few other writers.
I spent close to 1000 on buy-sell text testing articles from them as well.
I spent a couple of thousand on backlinks to get my site up to DA 30. Also several other small costs like canva, Ahrefs, Grammarly, etc.
The 6k I spent outsourcing the site from the start was a mistake and a learning experience for me. I thought I could pay someone to build a site for me and make money on it. I learned it was a bad idea. I listed it in this thread as such as well to help people not mess around with things and learn things yourself.
A lot of what I wrote is overestimating but id would say 7k was what was spent on the site that wasn't a complete waste. Such as backlinks, Ahrefs, Content.
Now, I am going to respond to your list of things I "should" do.
1. I do this already.
2. I have Ahrefs and have used it when trying to learn keyword research.
3. I will have to try this. Thanks.
4. I do this as well. Especially on my newer content. I have every single competitor in an excel sheet, all their keywords, all keywords related to them, how they write, how they structure each article, what they use for subheadings, etc.
5. This is what I have been doing for the last 4 months.
I don't really wanna touch on the rest but I know what a good backlink is. I follow several people over the years and have spent a lot of time learning things they have talked about.
I really wish I could be absolutely perfect and make my very first website a complete home run without any problems or learning but I don't think that's exactly possible. I have had a couple of people on here, who are actually very successful at this, look at my site and tell me my site looks fine and my keywords are all good. Exactly what they would do when creating a site. Not what I did at the start but what I am doing now.
I appreciate the constructive feedback though. Thanks for reading the thread.
Oh, and one more thing, since I didn't see it before, I never bought PBN links. To my knowledge, I did not mention anything about buying PBN links... I only bought guest posts, forums, and niche edits. I know a few really successful bloggers who are ONLY using forum links to rank and have had a lot of success with them. I used the same providers they used as well. Forum links are not useless. I am not sure where you got that information from either.