ReCaptcha works on 1 website but not another?

[Thuyn]

Signed up for 2 new accounts today. 1 at BHW and another at [Edited by a Mod]. Signing up at BHW was no issue. Unfortunately cannot get thru the captcha at [Edited by a Mod]. What issues could Possibly cause this? If someone NOT in USA wants to donate 5 minutes of their day and test it out and attempt to sign up at [Edited by a Mod] with fake info and see if they can get thru or not I would greatly appreciate it

 

[TomTheCat]

BHW doesn't use ReCaptcha. The problem you are facing is a proxy issue. The IP is blacklisted on Google ReCaptcha.

 

[Thuyn]

To clarify, I am able to click on the box beside “I’m not a robot” a green check mark appears, I click “register account” then nothing happens until the red “verification expired. Check the checkbox again” message appears. Try it again multiple times but it ends up in same cycle.

 

[TomTheCat]

To clarify, I am able to click on the box beside “I’m not a robot” a green check mark appears, I click “register account” then nothing happens until the red “verification expired. Check the checkbox again” message appears. Try it again multiple times but it ends up in same cycle.

Yeah. That is a proxy issue!

 

[luckybos]

Yeah. That is a proxy issue!

Thanks for the clarification. Is this automatically any proxy or is this proxy just low quality? Should I be using something else such as VPS?

 

[TomTheCat]

Thanks for the clarification. Is this automatically any proxy or is this proxy just low quality? Should I be using something else such as VPS?

This only Google knows why. Probably an abused IP address. Any other proxy/VPS should work.

 

[Thuyn]

UPDATE: So I tried registering on a sister website betanysports.eu. They have the same exact captcha routine and I am able to register easily but cannot do the same with 5Deurope.eu. So it’s probably not my IP address. Could some security settings of 5deurope be different that makes it harder to register compared to betanysports?

 

[Thuyn]

What exactly is the difference between Proxy and VPS and would one be more helpful in getting me thru the registration process than the other

 

[TomTheCat]

A proxy can be a datacenter or residential one. A VPS usually is on a datacenter. For your needs, you will need a proxy.

 

[Thuyn]

A data center proxy wouldn’t work. I’d need a residential proxy correct?

 

[TomTheCat]

Yes. Search marketplace.

 

[Thuyn]

I’ve tried soax and it doesn’t work with 5deurope. And scraping proxy comes up as VPN when typing IP address into whatsmyipaddress.com

 

[Thuyn]

But the weird thing is, as I previously mentioned. 2 sites that use the same exact sign up process with Recaptcha “I’m not a robot” at the end before clicking “register” works fine with betanysports.eu, doesn’t work with 5deurope.eu. Could 5deurope have tighter Recaptcha security settings than betanysports? Is that even possible? Sorry I’m not technical at all

 

[TomTheCat]

Probably they are fingerprinting you or they maintain a blacklist of proxies. You can also use an anti-detect browser and give it a try.

I've never used ReCaptcha (I don't know if there's any setting to tighten the security for this). I've encountered your issue on a website, and that's why I know there is a proxy issue.

 

[Thuyn]

I used soax residential proxy on GoLogin browser without success. Do you by chance know of a Canadian proxy provider that could help with my needs? My friend has posted in “want to buy” and I’ve done so too without any success

 

[Thuyn]

UPDATE so I talked to a friend in a different country than me and they also had issues registering for a new account on 5deurope with a normal home wifi connection. 5Deurope has the same exact Recaptcha process as the attached website with a “verification expired” message after 1-2 minutes. What could I tell the website’s IT department to lookout for so they could fix this issue?

https://patrickhlauke.github.io/recaptcha/
PS if anyone wants to donate 1-2 minutes of their time and test out the captcha and tell me their result and what type of internet connection they are using id greatly appreciate that!

 

[TomTheCat]

What could I tell the website’s IT department to lookout for so they could fix this issue?

Be short.

Hello,

I have an issue registering. See the video (upload it to a free platform)

Thank you!

And maybe make a small video. You can use ScreenRec so you can record only the part where you complete the captcha but won't let you register.