comment backlinks GSA? Xrumer?

[bromanager]

For generating comment backlinks, which one is more effective, GSA or Xrumer?

 

[kuruptseo]

they are both effective at TANKING your site.

honestly this is not a recommended approach anymore.

Few, hq, slow paced natural-looking links is the way forward.

 

[bromanager]

they are both effective at TANKING your site.

honestly this is not a recommended approach anymore.

Few, hq, slow paced natural-looking links is the way forward.

I want to create a comment-type backlink to blogger.com.
So I bought GSA, Xrumer, scrapebox, but I don't know which one to use.

 

[Deleted member 731332]

If you have all three why not use all three since you've paid for them? Make this determination yourself from your own data.

I'll tell you from my own actual data, however, as I use all three of these tools, currently. SER is the best for comments, for me. It is very good. Scrapebox is also very good for comments.

 

[fuad_2000]

xrumer is powerfull
and i have use it it really helpfull

and there new update for

XRumer 23 Strong AI​

 

[solidguy_82]

Scrapebox is good

 

[woguojun]

xrumer is powerfull
and i have use it it really helpfull

and there new update for

XRumer 23 Strong AI​

Where do you get the xrumer list ?

 

[fuad_2000]

Where do you get the xrumer list ?

what list ??

 

[Stuart Sergio]

Xrumer is powerful than GSA.

 

[team475]

xrumer is powerfull
and i have use it it really helpfull

and there new update for

XRumer 23 Strong AI​

the update wasn't released yet, just announced.

 

[SeoBacklinkGenie]

xrumer is powerfull
and i have use it it really helpfull

and there new update for

XRumer 23 Strong AI​

Preordered already, but I don't have high hopes. If its anything like xevil beta 6 itll be just a cash grab for almost identical product.

 

[team475]

Xrumer is powerful than GSA.

i use both, each is stronger in other fields.
i also tried each on different sites (and not the other), both worked OK.

hey are both effective at TANKING your site.

this is not true, if you know how to use these tools correctly.
even URL shorteners boost ranking if you know to use them right. proven over and over again.

 

[Spots Seo]

My opinion Xrumer

 

[elianaseo]

Both are Best, and I use Xrumer

 

[TopAlpha]

Xrumer is only for Forums
GSA has a lot of Engines.

 

[Deleted member 731332]

Xrumer is only for Forums
GSA has a lot of Engines.

Xrumer is also for blog comments.

It also has plugins that extend the functionality like social plugin for social network automation (Facebook etc)

 

[TopAlpha]

Maybe you have right, i use it a long time ago only for Forums. therefore i like GSA as it has much more flexibility and functionality even it is slower to post than Xrumer

 

[v_kumar36]

they are both effective at TANKING your site.

honestly this is not a recommended approach anymore.

Few, hq, slow paced natural-looking links is the way forward.

I am not an expert but just guessing that Google indexes backlinks periodically. If someone creates 5000 backlinks then indexing might take up to 3 months. In this case, indexing is slow, so Google notices it periodically. What is your expert opinion?

 

[710fla]

GSA since it allows me to tweak more filters to the sites I post

 

[TopAlpha]

Regarding indexing you can use indexing service and this is a lot or you can build with GSA other Tier then you can index your links easy.