Which link would you take

[west555]

Hypothetical question.

If you have option to get a link from 2 different sites. (guest post )

example

Site 1

DR 50
Traffic 40k per month
Generic ( it has Keywords related to your niche Ranked on page 1 )

Site 2

DR 80
Traffic 2mil
Generic website ( it has no related keywords ranked to your niche )

Both sites are from same country its same language


Would you take it from site 1 or site 2 and why ?

 

[Ranking Expert]

I will go with site 1

 

[perocJ]

I would definitely go with option number 1

 

[House of FEM]

I prefer 1st option

 

[west555]

I will go with site 1

I would definitely go with option number 1

I prefer 1st option

Why ?
Do you think link itself is more powerful because its kinda more relevant, or because of potential traffic you might get since Site 1 is ranked for some of those keywords ?

 

[lifehero]

site 2

 

[MrDenz]

I would think well of site 2, if the whole site is about games, for example, and I want a health article, I would go with option 1.

If #2 isn’t too aggressive and if it doesn’t look like "too much", I’d go with option 2.

 

[House of FEM]

Why ?
Do you think link itself is more powerful because its kinda more relevant, or because of potential traffic you might get since Site 1 is ranked for some of those keywords ?

As 1st option contains more relevant keywords I do prefer 1st option.

 

[west555]

I would think well of site 2, if the whole site is about games, for example, and I want a health article, I would go with option 1.

If #2 isn’t too aggressive and if it doesn’t look like "too much", I’d go with option 2.

Both are generic news sites,
just Site one lets say posted some news about the niche xx and got ranked naturally for those

 

[WebMath SEO]

Definitely, My option is site 1, It has keywords related to my niche, Relevancy is a must.

 

[west555]

Definitely, My option is site 1, It has keywords related to my niche, Relevancy is a must.

How much relevancy is enough ?

If i post a guest post on Site 2 it will also have keywords related to my niche

 

[Content Ninja]

Of course the one with more relevant keyword. Option 1

 

[joseph15]

give me site 2, at DR 80 topical relevancy doesn't matter... just check the rankings for the most competitive affiliate keywords right now.

 

[breakcode]

Good question, probably i take the DR80 one

 

[WebMath SEO]

How much relevancy is enough ?

If i post a guest post on Site 2 it will also have keywords related to my niche

If site 2 has relevant keywords for your niche, You can post there It has a good DR metric but Also make sure to do guest posts under the relevant category.

 

[tazarbm]

damn, that's a tough one. I'd pick site 2, though for the extra authority and traffic. I know that the traffic might be unrelated to your niche, but then again, it's a generic niche so some of that traffic might be interested in your niche at any time. And since the price is the same for both websites the double authority might make the difference

 

[west555]

If site 2 has relevant keywords for your niche, You can post there It has a good DR metric but Also make sure to do guest posts under the relevant category.

Point is it doesn't have, but since we are talking about Guest post once you post it, it will have, so is Site 1 really more relavant in that case?

 

[HustleTong]

Second one if your niche isn't too specific

 

[Logicaldot]

I will get both sites

 

[west555]

I will get both sites

You cant get both, Point is to choose between them as you only can take one