PBN or 301 Redirect

[Sheraz Ali]

Which Method has the more weightage PBN or 301 redirect in 2019... I have a domain having backlinks from high authority sites and 90,200 pages index in google. i want these links to be beneficial for my money site so what i have to choose. i have to go with PBN or Redirect a whole domain to my money sites... please guide me to get maximum power of this opportunity...

 

[SirLouen]

PBN all the way. From my point of view, 301 is a weird way to kill powerful domains.

 

[Real GuestPost]

PBN. You can pass on the link juice to not only 1 sites but multiple sites.

 

[Seeo]

PBN

 

[SEO JOKER]

In my opinion, PBN is the best one.

 

[Jay Yadav]

+1 For PBN!

 

[IamNRE]

mix it up. PBN + some pages from high PR domains that 301 redirect to your page (not I said pages, not the whole domain).

 

[AngelSeo]

As always, its depends.

People saying "PBN" without knowing the full picture ... think again maybe? Whats the point of building a PBN of domain worth $500 if you have just one money website so you can link once? You can buy a ridiculously strong guest post (or 5 decent ones) for that kind of money without the extra expenses of building the PBN, hosting and so on.

However you cannot really overdo 301s - as this may get you penalty. So if you have really good niche related domain for the 301 - go for it. Otherwise - build a PBN.

 

[Unreliable Witness]

As always, its depends.

People saying "PBN" without knowing the full picture ... think again maybe? Whats the point of building a PBN of domain worth $500 if you have just one money website so you can link once? You can buy a ridiculously strong guest post (or 5 decent ones) for that kind of money without the extra expenses of building the PBN, hosting and so on.

This is a simplified answer but the advantage of a link from a PBN lies in the ratio of inbound to outbound links. Most sites that allow guest posts will have many outbound links, so even with a high number of inbound links, "power" or "juice" credited to your site will be low.

On a PBN, you can limit the outbound links, and therefore give a higher proportion of the power, even if the total power to the site is less.

And of course, power isn't the only factor, but it is an important one.

 

[alexio]

PRO/CON

PBN : can me used for multiple websites/products
301 redirect : only one

PBN setup + content + hosting : cost $$$$
301 redirect: free

 

[Seen Here Online]

PBN for me !

 

[webdim]

As always, its depends.

People saying "PBN" without knowing the full picture ... think again maybe? Whats the point of building a PBN of domain worth $500 if you have just one money website so you can link once? You can buy a ridiculously strong guest post (or 5 decent ones) for that kind of money without the extra expenses of building the PBN, hosting and so on.

However you cannot really overdo 301s - as this may get you penalty. So if you have really good niche related domain for the 301 - go for it. Otherwise - build a PBN.

@AngelSeo

What about if I own a premium ($500 with very good metrics) domain and the niche is not perfectly much but is related let's say about 75%? What is your opinion about it, 301 or use it as a PBN?

 

[AngelSeo]

@AngelSeo

What about if I own a premium ($500 with very good metrics) domain and the niche is not perfectly much but is related let's say about 75%? What is your opinion about it, 301 or use it as a PBN?

I have seen way too much even completely irrelevant 301s working like a charm nowadays, that I would say - go for it. Yes, its a hit or miss situation, but the benefits if it work are outweighing single PBN link by much. Ill send you an example in PM.