Question: 2 Domains; 1 Stronger but Generic, and 1 Specific

[hoodbgoode]

Say you are working with two sites.

Option 1:

Domain A, (stronger, say 25 DA / 25 PA)

General running site with greater amounts of news and content
pillar page: generalrunning.com/nikerunningshoes

Option 2:

Domain B (weaker, say 12 DA / 10 pa)

Nike running shoes site
Less content, total, than option 1

nikerunningshoes.com

which of these domain options is better positioned to rank for 'nike running shoes'?

Pillar page from 1, or domain from 2?


(i know both domains would have a super hard time ranking for nike running shoes, but just checking which domain would be able to get on page 1 first, all other things being equal)

 

[hoodbgoode]

anyone?

 

[RAP]

Page 1 for: nike running shoes?
Good luck.

 

[hoodbgoode]

Page 1 for: nike running shoes?
Good luck.

Completely ignored the point and spirit of the post, no one here is dumb enough to target that keyword.

Good job.

 

[hoodbgoode]

bump