Why didn't classified AD in national magazine do anything?

Fred2507

Registered Member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
60
Reaction score
7
I put an ad in Enquirer, for a dating site.. and it didn't do shit.
I expected that maybe .1% of the readers would see the classifieds (5000) and maybe .5% of those would buy a membership (25) x $40 would be at least $1000 .. the ad cost $150

Dating site would be perfect for a tabloid, I thought.. where the **** did I go all wrong? I had ONE unique visitor. . . I know it wasn't the sponsor shaving sales or not tracking my traffic .. had my own counter .. ONE HIT

What the hell happened??
 

biks

Power Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2008
Messages
719
Reaction score
386
I think those dating lawn signs beat you to it! :)
 

flightrisk

Junior Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2009
Messages
141
Reaction score
61
Hummm I would think you would get some traffic here...have you placed an ad here before...did the ad run...I think with these things you want to see the ad in print.
 

Fred2507

Registered Member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
60
Reaction score
7
Hummm I would think you would get some traffic here...have you placed an ad here before...did the ad run...I think with these things you want to see the ad in print.

Yeah, it definitely ran... I saw in in the Enq here, and had someone in Cali and another person in DE buy one and see that it was there...
 

angelas111

Elite Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2009
Messages
1,647
Reaction score
1,051
that's because print is dead. except for old folks...........advertise a geriatric dating site and you might get some hits............if they have a computer.
 

flightrisk

Junior Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2009
Messages
141
Reaction score
61
that's because print is dead. except for old folks...........advertise a geriatric dating site and you might get some hits............if they have a computer.
not sure its dead.... i do think its an untapped market, because of your thinking, to OP you may want to do some split testing, but thats the problem with print...cost and time

btw the only reason i responded to this is, i think it deserves a bump...because print media is overlooked and it may need some more input
 

Fred2507

Registered Member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
60
Reaction score
7
I was thinking, 5M "readers", should have gotten me at least 5 sales... If they say 5M readers it is probably only 1M circulation, but, Enquirer only goes out 1M times, really?? I mean hell who knows..
 

agente808

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
458
Reaction score
198
First, I would say you might be targeting the wrong offer for your audience - who reads tabloids? Your answer might range from "women" to "Loosers" but.....

Did you do your research?
Code:
http://search.rja-ads.com/pdfs/demographics/natenq-demographics.pdf

(same as above in html)
http://74.125.47.132/search?q=cache:f_Jlk-a9Lm8J:www.americanmediainc.com/mediakits/ne/pdf/ne_mediakit_all.pdf+national+enquirer+readership&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk

http://www.americanmediainc.com/mediakits/ne/pdf/ne_mediakit_all.pdf

(same as above in html)
http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:91yg43HdHvsJ:search.rja-ads.com/pdfs/demographics/natenq-demographics.pdf+national+enquirer+readership&hl=en&sig=AHIEtbQRSQY6z8jOHeLgAHgzIbHvnjkmqQ

These media kits from the National Inquierer TELL YOU what products to target with their audience - and guess what - NO dating products are mentioned... Over 50% of the readership is married, most have children (a high number have 3 or more)

Try this again with:
diet / health / beauty (acai berry anyone?)
DVDs and movies
convenience products for parents / products for children

KNOW YOUR AUDIENCE, you can't just dump anything in front of any group and expect to get the same result
 

Fred2507

Registered Member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
60
Reaction score
7
First, I would say you might be targeting the wrong offer for your audience - who reads tabloids? Your answer might range from "women" to "Loosers" but.....

Did you do your research?
Code:
http://search.rja-ads.com/pdfs/demographics/natenq-demographics.pdf

(same as above in html)
http://74.125.47.132/search?q=cache:f_Jlk-a9Lm8J:www.americanmediainc.com/mediakits/ne/pdf/ne_mediakit_all.pdf+national+enquirer+readership&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk

http://www.americanmediainc.com/mediakits/ne/pdf/ne_mediakit_all.pdf

(same as above in html)
http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:91yg43HdHvsJ:search.rja-ads.com/pdfs/demographics/natenq-demographics.pdf+national+enquirer+readership&hl=en&sig=AHIEtbQRSQY6z8jOHeLgAHgzIbHvnjkmqQ
These media kits from the National Inquierer TELL YOU what products to target with their audience - and guess what - NO dating products are mentioned... Over 50% of the readership is married, most have children (a high number have 3 or more)

Try this again with:
diet / health / beauty (acai berry anyone?)
DVDs and movies
convenience products for parents / products for children

KNOW YOUR AUDIENCE, you can't just dump anything in front of any group and expect to get the same result


WoW
This board has coherent people everywhere
You're right
I didn't even look at the demos
I just assumed that there were alot of lonely women and men reading tabloids.... and was thinking quantity over quality.. stupid. Sigh.
 

Fred2507

Registered Member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
60
Reaction score
7
yea dude y u do a dating site my lawn signs beat u to it lol......use a weight loss next time ur target audience in that mag are married moms many that squeezed out puppies and are lookin to drop that baby weight
Posted via Mobile Device

Do yard stickers work for dating sites??
I have great domains for billboards or yard stickers.. Like D8CA.com D8NV.com D8LA.com etc .. not using them for anything rigt now
But 4 characters and coherent is PERFECT for those signs..
 

Fred2507

Registered Member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
60
Reaction score
7
First, I would say you might be targeting the wrong offer for your audience - who reads tabloids? Your answer might range from "women" to "Loosers" but.....

Did you do your research?
Code:
http://search.rja-ads.com/pdfs/demographics/natenq-demographics.pdf

(same as above in html)
http://74.125.47.132/search?q=cache:f_Jlk-a9Lm8J:www.americanmediainc.com/mediakits/ne/pdf/ne_mediakit_all.pdf+national+enquirer+readership&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk

http://www.americanmediainc.com/mediakits/ne/pdf/ne_mediakit_all.pdf

(same as above in html)
http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:91yg43HdHvsJ:search.rja-ads.com/pdfs/demographics/natenq-demographics.pdf+national+enquirer+readership&hl=en&sig=AHIEtbQRSQY6z8jOHeLgAHgzIbHvnjkmqQ
These media kits from the National Inquierer TELL YOU what products to target with their audience - and guess what - NO dating products are mentioned... Over 50% of the readership is married, most have children (a high number have 3 or more)

Try this again with:
diet / health / beauty (acai berry anyone?)
DVDs and movies
convenience products for parents / products for children

KNOW YOUR AUDIENCE, you can't just dump anything in front of any group and expect to get the same result



But at the same time... a supposed readership of nearly 10M and I got ONE unique visitor?? Really?? Sigh :rolleyes:
 

agente808

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
458
Reaction score
198
But at the same time... a supposed readership of nearly 10M and I got ONE unique visitor?? Really??
Well, I'd have to say that maybe your ad copy wasn't compelling - and that's really the downside to print advertising - there's no easy way to do A/B testing...

As for advertising your offline domains - how about you print up a ton of cheap stickers and postcards (but nice looking!) and leave them in bathrooms in bars or other places guys hang out - your target audience is guys 18-?? - so think about where to target guys...
Car wash - you can ask / pay the owner to leave postcards
Sports events - one post on here (not my idea, probably a good idea to search for it) suggested handing out stuff at baseball games... or you could leave them in the car windshields in the parking lot of sports games...

There are lots of ideas you could come up with if you brainstorm...
 

agente808

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
458
Reaction score
198
oh yeah - and sex sells with IMAGES - so make sure you are putting some good (but not x-rated) pics on your ads / stickers / postcards...

Did your magazine ad have an image or was it just text?
 

Fred2507

Registered Member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
60
Reaction score
7
Man, I love the way people on this board think.. Jesus, the baseball game idea is beautiful. You could pay five idiots to get every car there. And you can't do better than an audience that is, what, 75% men(Maybe 25% women/children??)?? Targeting women is becoming a really really good idea for adult sites and dating, too, I think. Of course you need the right kind of content / dating site.

The magazine AD I thought I was being clever with it.. $150 buys 10 words, right, well instead of that I bought a 14C headline ad.... Basically the ad was the website in bigger bold letters.

The headline could be as many as X characters and my website fit it perfectly

WWW.FINDYOURLOVERNOW.COM
The ad looked just exactly like this

I know not to use long domain names but I thought that it was a clever way to put the ad up..
 

fastmoney

Newbie
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
36
Reaction score
13
Base ball idea. No work..Problem is you would get thrown off the lot in the first 10 minutes.. But try it..
 

robertodelgato

Regular Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2009
Messages
360
Reaction score
3,207
You want to advertise in PCWorld magazine if you want to find lonely, horny guys. They'll also read the classifieds since that's where all the good hardware deals are. :D



WoW
This board has coherent people everywhere
You're right
I didn't even look at the demos
I just assumed that there were alot of lonely women and men reading tabloids.... and was thinking quantity over quality.. stupid. Sigh.
 

agente808

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
458
Reaction score
198
I like your domain name, not too long at all, easy to remember...

Trying to sell to women is a great idea, but it's a totally different pitch - women need more of a write-up, and you would want to focus on actual matchmaking sites (think eharmony)

...actually, the PCWorld magazine doesn't sound too bad to me.... especially if you find a way to connect with your audience: "chat live with princess leah look-alike" hahaha
 
Top