the way I did blog commenting did not work - could you show me my mistakes?

Hi, I read a bunch about blog commenting and tried to do it a little bit over the past 5 months.

1st "way": I did a search on Google with a query:
<my keyword> +comment -"You must be logged in" -"comments off" -"please sign in" +"You may use these HTML tags"

From this way I recorded in my Excel 74 comments that I made and from these 74 naturally not all were approved, maybe half and from those only 5 appeared recognised in the Google Webmaster Tools. So a "success" rate of only 6.5%. :dunno:

2nd "way" I did I joined disqus commenting platform and there, out of 59, and although approval rate is almost 100% by nature, 0 appeared recognised in the Google Webmaster Tools. So a "success" rate of 0.0%. :lame:

_________________________

Could you tell me what am I doing wrong? How can I increase my success rate so I can get some links for my website?

Thank you very much! :help:

Kikos said:

1st "way": I did a search on Google with a query:
<my keyword> +comment -"You must be logged in" -"comments off" -"please sign in" +"You may use these HTML tags"

Click to expand...

Scale up and try different footprints. Some examples here:
http://www.blackhatworld.com/blackhat-seo/black-hat-seo-tools/347094-scrapebox-footprints.html

Some platforms can be picky and for example, are not keen if you are using a keyword for a name; so try using a person's name. Write a useful, relevant comment.

Kikos said:

2nd "way" I did I joined disqus commenting platform and there, out of 59, and although approval rate is almost 100% by nature, 0 appeared recognised in the Google Webmaster Tools.

Click to expand...

Disqus comments aren't indexed in Google:
http://www.blackhatworld.com/blackh...-pr4-7-backlinks-while-reading-newspaper.html

So avoid it.

What are you doing wrong? You haven't invested $57 in Scrapebox my friend. Only manually comment on high PR sites, automate the rest.

Ok, I understand that there are many footprints, but I wanted to know if there was a mistake in how I did it that I only got 6.5% success rate and what can I do, if anything, to increase this success rate?

P.S.
To: SEOWhizz, thanks
To: lafours, thanks, yes, I am asking about the manual high PR, how to increase my success rate

so this 6% success rate is normal?
if i could please check again if anymore feedback would be possible on this point if there is a way to increase my success chances

thanks!

If you're doing manual high pr blog commenting, I posted a method where I use comment footprints to return thousands of do follow blogs. You can just modify the method a bit to include topical blogs related to your niche.

The thread is HERE