let's say you buy a domain for PBN you are trying to rebuild it using archive.org but there is one problem: all of the text has already been used in other sites so you will get in trouble for plagiarism. Here is how that can happen: the expired domain that you bought used to have some content. This content was copied by web scrapers or whatever. then your domain expired, and gone for a long time. now if you put the original content on your domain, it will look like you are copying it from those other sites. so your PBN will get in trouble for this kind of "plagiarism"? how important is it to rebuild a site anyway? wouldn't it be better to put all original content?
Unless you want to stay Supersafe you should rebuild it. But i don't think it's necessary. I have successfully ranked medium and higher competitive niche with my Isabella PBN of new original content. Even on BHW, my service has help people to increase ranking by a lot. You will hardly get caught, unless you start bragging how you pawn Google and do as big as like BMR. There are so many network outthere , Google will kill them first. Your small network should 99.99% will not get caught. So you don't have to worry for now.
I am not worried about getting caught, I am just worried about algorithmic penalties for plagiarism. I would like to put all brand new content, but I read somewhere that if you put brand new content, your backlinks will get devalued or not counted. For example, let's say the original site had 5 paragraphs. everybody linked to the site. Then, the 5 paragraphs are removed and replaced with 5 brand new paragraphs. people didn't link to your new paragraphs, they linked to the old ones. so it would make sense if backlinks do indeed get devalued due to a site being completely different. so you have ranked using all brand new content? you didn't give a shit what the site used to look like before?
Your 5 paragraphs i suppose is 5 pages. The 5 links will not get devalue, if you build back the same link. Example : domain/page1 , and you build back the same url with new content. The link juice pass the same. Where did you get the info from? You only lose the domain power, when it link to a 404 page. BUT It can be resolve by a plugin. (Which will reduce the power overtime) I ranked with Spinned content, i don't give a sh*t , yup. I am ranking top 10 within 1 month. lol. That why i dare to give you my opinion, i tested and proven it.
I usually not rebuild them but redirect those pages to main page or article and tell you what I see no difference how DA/PA staid same still same
I dont remember where I got that information, it is a google patent. but google is usually full of shit so I trust your experience more. why do you rebuild the old url structure? couldn't you make the homepage ONLY, and 301 redirect all non-existing pages to homepage? how many pages is each site in your PBN? I thought just a homepage is enough?
I just use a plugin to redirect all 404 to homepage. And i build my own content when i need to link out. I make sure all PBN got about us and contact us. That all, and the rest are post
