Need Advice

Would you like to have a domain name which is previously redirected in the same niche or different niche
Example - A domain previously in the fishing niche but redirected to in a furniture niche so, it it be a offense in the eyes of Google? or it would be advisable to have a domains name which has no such history like if it is redirected to any domain then, it should be relevant to the niche in the past such as a fishing niche domain created in the past must be used for fishing purposes only not for furniture, tech, etc

Using a domain previously redirected in the same niche can be beneficial for its reputation and authority, but if it has been redirected to a completely different niche in the past, Google might view it as suspicious. It's generally better to use a domain with a relevant history to avoid potential penalties and maintain trust with Google. If you can't find a relevant domain with a clean history, proceed with caution and ensure it has no spammy backlinks or suspicious activity.

Redirect is a one way street, so it shouldn't matter as much really, but who knows what Google comes up with in the future.

Also, these are signs that the domain was a part of a SEO campaign, so I would be concerned what other ordeals the domain went through besides the redirect. Shitty link building, etc.

All in all, stick with stuff that is not suspicious and wasn't part of any SEO.