It's actually surprising that you haven't tried to monetize this database
I would have thought you'd be sending them at least weekly tips and slipping in an affiliate product or two now and again. Periodically, you could review or recommend products that are related to the niche.
Perhaps you can also segment the list. What I mean is that folks interested in dating might also be interested in sports, weight loss, public speaking, etc., so you could maybe include such offers (e.g. as a solo ad or as a 2 liner ad in your newsletter) when doing your mailing.
Of course, shameless and "full court press" type pitch-fest emails that just sell and sell and sell might not work so well, but opinions regarding such marketing methods differ
Hmm.. you actually have the "assets" for setting a bunch of JVs too
May I contact you for JV campaigns
Heh... start monetizing your list, ok?
Cheerio
:flame: