Magic Submitter vs. SEnuke X vs. Sick Submitter vs. SEOLinkRobot and More!

flexnds

Power Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2010
Messages
643
Reaction score
699
I see info/reviews requested for these all the time. I think this is a very good review of these tools. So for anyone thinking about purchasing any of these, check out this video. NOT MY VIDEO.

Magic Submitter vs. SEnuke X vs. Sick Submitter vs. SEOLinkRobot and More!

[youtube]HnNB06OiEqs[/youtube]
 
Are there people out there who would agree that sick submitter is really powerful if you're a programmer/geeky type? As in -- if you customize it enough it is on par with senukex?

Thanks, great video.
 
Very good comparison.. i havent used Magic Submitter but his usability review is quite accurate for SenukeX and Sick Marketing
 
Are there people out there who would agree that sick submitter is really powerful if you're a programmer/geeky type? As in -- if you customize it enough it is on par with senukex?

Thanks, great video.

How difficult is sick submitter? I have senukex and i'll be picking up magic submitter again i think.. I hope they have improved it since 4 months ago.
 
How difficult is sick submitter? I have senukex and i'll be picking up magic submitter again i think.. I hope they have improved it since 4 months ago.
Yes, Magic Submitter has been improved. It's a lot better than before. Give it a try again my friend ;)
 
You can actually replace Magic S altogether with combination of IMacros and Roboform. That way you have no monthly payments and no friggin long drawn out learning curve. Or, you can use ZennoPoster, which has a steep learning curve but it is the Mercedes Benz of automation...;)

Frankly, even with the improvements, I disagree with the assessment about Magic S. I had it for almost five months x $67.00 p/m and unless you are a programmer or an extremely patient Internet Marketer, it won't work for you. The main issue is that MS "IS NOT" intuitive any any shape, form or fashion! People who tell you otherwise, are either: MS affiliates, programmers, coders, probably graduated Cum Laude or higher, or they are mathematical wizards.

Here is the bottom line...

There are certain software applications that are designed to be intuitive. Meaning, that they have an instinctive flow that allows users to figure the software out without a lot of head scratching or cursing at their monitors. With MS, [unless you are a programmer type] you will be head scratching, guaranteed.
 
Why didn't you include Xrumer? It is better than all of these combined.
 
You can actually replace Magic S altogether with combination of IMacros and Roboform. That way you have no monthly payments and no friggin long drawn out learning curve. Or, you can use ZennoPoster, which has a steep learning curve but it is the Mercedes Benz of automation...;)

Frankly, even with the improvements, I disagree with the assessment about Magic S. I had it for almost five months x $67.00 p/m and unless you are a programmer or an extremely patient Internet Marketer, it won't work for you. The main issue is that MS "IS NOT" intuitive any any shape, form or fashion! People who tell you otherwise, are either: MS affiliates, programmers, coders, probably graduated Cum Laude or higher, or they are mathematical wizards.

Here is the bottom line...

There are certain software applications that are designed to be intuitive. Meaning, that they have an instinctive flow that allows users to figure the software out without a lot of head scratching or cursing at their monitors. With MS, [unless you are a programmer type] you will be head scratching, guaranteed.

Understandable, but SEO in itself is incredibly time consuming. From keyword research, hiring writers, reviewing content, launching sites with good on page optimization, then taking care of link building. It's understandable that a tech guy such as yourself would say this. However, the time spent managing the software, customizing it, fixing dead sites, fixing crap everytime a site changes something, etc is a fulltime job by itself. So this is why I prefer something good out of the box.

Don't get me wrong, if you are willing to take on those responsibilities and or can program a software to be super smart, then go for it. However, I am launching tons of sites, so to even think of managing something like this would be ridiculous. The guy in the video also makes a good point about people simply not using programs if they are a chore to use in the first place.
 
very good review. i m currently in the selecting process and these 3 tools are on my list :) so thanks for that. given that time is a big factor i probably go with senuke (and you can share a license too so it's actually not that expensive)
 
Nice review... Used SEnuke and seolinkrobot several times, have had good experiences... All of them have their ins and outs.
 
Are there people out there who would agree that sick submitter is really powerful if you're a programmer/geeky type? As in -- if you customize it enough it is on par with senukex?

Thanks, great video.

I am also very interested in the answer to this. I have been looking through videos and what-not but as a programmer, I think I'd end up loving it. There aren't too many recent success story threads that I can see on their forums, though there is a lot of activity.

It's also on sale until Dec 1st. lol. I guess the next version is also in Beta.
 
Def a good review. Could have added screens of the UI for people to see because I think with a good program a good UI should be included as well.
 
Are there people out there who would agree that sick submitter is really powerful if you're a programmer/geeky type? As in -- if you customize it enough it is on par with senukex?

Thanks, great video.

I will argue that it can be more powerful, there is already a web 2.0 packet for sick that you can buy for like $50. Packets are like plugins that you embed in sick and they can then be used to interact with forums, article directories, blogs, whatever you want. The thing about packets is that when you get one, you get the source code along with it, so you can make changes to the code. They have developed a programming language called sic specifically for that purpose (more details about that language-> http://help.sickmarketing.com/), if you're a programmer you'll quickly learn the basics of that and you'll be able to start doing some very interesting things with it, as a programmer myself I was surprised by how well designed this software is, it's very rare to see good software in this industry.
 
Back
Top