Dentist Threatens To Sue Over Bad Yelp Comments

jonnyquest

jonnyquest

Regular Member
Joined
Nov 24, 2008
Messages
277
Reaction score
447
What a story ..

http://gma.yahoo.com/blogs/abc-blogs/dentist-threatens-sue-patient-negative-yelp-review-131752629.html

To say the least it is ugly but wondering how an Offline Consultant would advise a client like this Dentist on how to manage the bad PR she is getting.

JQ
 
Advertise on BHW
Wow sending $100 a day invoices for keeping the content online is dumb and on top of that why such the huge bill? That is why he had the patient sign that form in the first place. Nice find man.
 
I would find another dentist to help. Chances are these type of dentist/client will use the same legal tactic on all their dealings, including to the offline consultant themselves.

I always look out for red flags, what they do to others will often what they will do to you.

Plus, why not use your skills to help those who are worthy of your help?

More for their competitors.
 
jonnyquest said:
What a story ..

http://gma.yahoo.com/blogs/abc-blogs/dentist-threatens-sue-patient-negative-yelp-review-131752629.html

To say the least it is ugly but wondering how an Offline Consultant would advise a client like this Dentist on how to manage the bad PR she is getting.

JQ
Click to expand...

I provide Reputation Management like this quite often to some of my offline clients. Fighting negative reputation can be hard, but there are some things you can do:

  • Try getting the page removed by claiming that practice no longer exists and then put it back up
  • Try and claim the reviews as spam or a competitor back this up by pointing out short comings in their yelp account (few reviews, few friends, etc)
  • Try and focus on bringing up the positive reviews
  • As the business owner reply to the comment and try and explain the otherside of the story

Reputation can be hard to manage but not impossible, also you can try beating out Yelp in the searches with a review microsite of your own
 
Um wow. She's promoting her CD on the front page of her website. Since being found out, she's gotten about 45 more bad reviews.
 
marusia said:
Um wow. She's promoting her CD on the front page of her website. Since being found out, she's gotten about 45 more bad reviews.
Click to expand...

LOLOL, just saw her yelp. It's getting hammered with negative reviews.

Code: 
http://www.yelp.com/biz/stacy-makhnevich-dds-new-york
 
Lol sues over bad rep and as a result, gets an even worse rep.
 
$100 per day......hahaha this is ridiculous.

I can't believe how people waste their time and energy. At the same time this is a good example how critical yelp is to local businesses.
 
thedon23 said:
LOLOL, just saw her yelp. It's getting hammered with negative reviews.

Code: 
http://www.yelp.com/biz/stacy-makhnevich-dds-new-york
Click to expand...

Thanks all for the response ... she has the "Herman Cain Syndrome" ...all it takes is one and everybody else piles on.

She will never get rid of those negative reviews now .. ha

JQ
 
thedon23 said:
LOLOL, just saw her yelp. It's getting hammered with negative reviews.

Code: 
*snip* can't post urls *snip*
Click to expand...

Ahaha, yeah. She's really not thought this through. She now just comes across as extremely shady and out to rip people off. She's probably destroyed her business when all she had to do was hand the documents over to the guy so he could pass them on to his insurance company. Complete and utter madness.
 
LOL one of the reviews:
"This chick may be totally unethical but I give her 5 stars for her great set of tits." :D
 
Without knowing all that was in the confidentiality agreement I would assume that the law is one the dentist's side. Confidentiality agreements are not a breech of freedom of speech because no one is coerced to use them. This man could have gone to another dentist if he didn't feel right about it. He chose to stay with her because of the pain. She did not cause the pain, she fixed it. For a New York dentist $100 per day sounds reasonable when it comes to damages. It may have even been a clause in the contract, we don't know.

He broke the contract and now he is going to have to pay the consequences.

Those additional yelp reviews will not hold since it is very clear that they have never used her service.

Yes, she comes off as a bitch. I personally don't care if a dentist is a bitch. I care about if they get the job done well. With the patient in question she got the job done well. The problem was with how the office handled the paperwork.
 
LBrown said:
Without knowing all that was in the confidentiality agreement I would assume that the law is one the dentist's side. Confidentiality agreements are not a breech of freedom of speech because no one is coerced to use them. This man could have gone to another dentist if he didn't feel right about it. He chose to stay with her because of the pain. She did not cause the pain, she fixed it. For a New York dentist $100 per day sounds reasonable when it comes to damages. It may have even been a clause in the contract, we don't know.

He broke the contract and now he is going to have to pay the consequences.

Those additional yelp reviews will not hold since it is very clear that they have never used her service.

Yes, she comes off as a bitch. I personally don't care if a dentist is a bitch. I care about if they get the job done well. With the patient in question she got the job done well. The problem was with how the office handled the paperwork.
Click to expand...

Pretty sure the paperwork is part of "the job", so she didn't exactly do the job well.

And I think the issue people have is that if you're having patients sign such a contract, then you might be hiding something.

My dentist has never made me sign such a contract, and he has a 5 star rating on Yelp.
 
Maybe a valid defence would be that he was in distress and could not make reasonable decisions. I guess some judges, juries whatever would agree that not many people can think clearly when in pain.

It is also a question of local law whether emergency treatments can be tied to a willingness to waive stuff. Otherwise first thing in the E.R. would be to sign forms agreeing not to talk.
LBrown said:
Without knowing all that was in the confidentiality agreement I would assume that the law is one the dentist's side. Confidentiality agreements are not a breech of freedom of speech because no one is coerced to use them. This man could have gone to another dentist if he didn't feel right about it. He chose to stay with her because of the pain. She did not cause the pain, she fixed it. For a New York dentist $100 per day sounds reasonable when it comes to damages. It may have even been a clause in the contract, we don't know.

He broke the contract and now he is going to have to pay the consequences.

Those additional yelp reviews will not hold since it is very clear that they have never used her service.

Yes, she comes off as a bitch. I personally don't care if a dentist is a bitch. I care about if they get the job done well. With the patient in question she got the job done well. The problem was with how the office handled the paperwork.
Click to expand...
 
I think the big picture here is that most people don't like to do business with a SHADY person like this. I mean, if you're offering a legit service, why would you be worried about people leaving you negative reviews?

Unless the person is a psychopath, I've never heard of a customer/patient/client leaving a bad review when they were pleased with the service they received. Makes no sense at all.

I do realize in some cases a business owner does need to cover their own ass, but prohibiting the customer to leave reviews? Sounds shady.
 
Last edited:
damn her business is pretty much ruined now. what a fucking bitch for suing her patient
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Networking Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting Hosting Images, Logos & Videos Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Misc

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping

BlackHatWorld

BHW Merch Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge Dispute Resolution

Other

Domain Name Forum IM Journeys Web Hosting Newsletter
Back
Top