• Please take a moment to look over the Suggestions & Feedback rules before making a post: READ RULES HERE

The vast majority of HAF and WTB threads are bots/shills

INCC

Elite Member
Jr. Executive VIP
Jr. VIP
Joined
Feb 12, 2018
Messages
5,156
Reaction score
6,594
The vast majority of the WTB/HAF service requests are fake.

Those sections have been completely overtaken by spam... the service owners are creating the requests via alt accounts, then are replying with the Jr.VIP/Premium accounts that they own. Usually, they own a whole network of accounts; it is a complete spam fest there.

The grift is the following:

  • Create an alt account and make a WTB/HAF thread.
  • Use your network of seller accounts to reply
  • Get the thread on the homepage in hopes that someone needs similar services and contacts you

It's not something they could get from the marketplace, right?


Screenshot 2026-11-16 193325.webp


Has this new grift been green-lighted by the staff? If not, then why isn't it removed or dealt with? I can see many of you online all the time, but the spam remains on the homepage.
 
As a buyer I've got a ton of DMs from different accounts that felt like the same person (Identical pricing, language, tone, payment method).
Hard to figure who is actually a legit seller
 
After we implemented the form, we got rid of many bot accounts, and anyone who doesn’t read the OP’s post and requirements will have their comment deleted and receive an infraction too.
 
After we implemented the form, we got rid of many bot accounts, and anyone who doesn’t read the OP’s post and requirements will have their comment deleted and receive an infraction too.
I don't think you read my post. This isn't about what you are talking about.
 
The spam from the HAF and WTB threads is unreal. If you go through these threads, almost all of the sellers don't bother reading the requirements and paste a generic AI generated reply.
There are 2 different types of spam.

The first one is what you and @Salamouna described.

The other is a completely different type of game where the sellers themselves create the HAF/WTB threads just so they can reply with their alts.
 
Why would the sellers do such a thing?
Because:
1) those posts rank on Google
2) those posts rank on BHW internal search system
3) those posts receive organic views

People looking for "google local guide level 10 accounts" can find those posts.

Often, instead of creating a new post, we just search for previous related ones and we see the answers to check potential sellers, easier than creating a new thread.

The real question is: why would someone ask it as the first comment on this forum?
 
I'd be down to see that section gone, but that's just my opinion.
That would just take a major chunk of forum's revenue away.
There needs to be a better solution.
I often browse HAF threads and some of them get 20-30 replies within minutes. It doesn't feel organic in any way.
Spam control needs to be better, even if it means deploying more mods/staff members to do manual clean ups.
 
I think AI generated replies are a big part of the problem. You often see the same generic ChatGPT pitch under different services. If you are a buyer that gets tiring and it makes BHW less valuable when you are actually looking for someone reliable.
 
My suggestion is a marketplace fee (that also acts like an escrow). This will eliminate time wasters and people with multiple accounts trying to game the system. To post on HAF/WTB, one must deposit the amount that they are willing to pay for the service into a BHW escrow. There is a fixed fee for services less than 500 USD in value and a small % for services above 501 USD. Additionally, this will also let the mods know which sellers deliver said service. The success rate of a service provider can be put on a leaderboard. This will increase the revenue and also lower the expenditure in monitoring bots/multiple accounts that only pay a fixed 100 USD fee a year.

This will eliminate a lot of people who are just trying to link jack and rank on Google.

Also, new rules for bumping: people only being able to reply if there is a message/question. Otherwise, an auto-bump feature that can be purchased for said credits

Example of a link jack on Google:

1794978461042.webp

Plus, they also tend to rank via BHW search.

Another thing I noticed is the Media section:

1. Banned members still have their services rank on BHW search via an image that has their contacts
2. Members without an approved sales thread have their media image for a said service that ranks above a verified sales thread

1794978743418.webp1794978743425.webp



---------------------------------------

Probably needs a few things legally addressed with the accountant, or move the registered company to a country that is easy on escrow businesses. UK is good for standard fiat payments
1794978105923.webp

While in theory it's easy for me to give a suggestion like the above, there would be a lot of practical hurdles and a sunk cost involved.
 
That would just take a major chunk of forum's revenue away.
There needs to be a better solution.
I often browse HAF threads and some of them get 20-30 replies within minutes. It doesn't feel organic in any way.
Spam control needs to be better, even if it means deploying more mods/staff members to do manual clean ups.

I agree with this points, I personally feel that, I replied over serveral HAF/WBT section but still now i get replied frome 1 or 2 account,

Most of them Just create a post and leave in the same minutes and back to forum over period of 1 or 2 month,

I'm also request to the Mod/Staff memebers to keep follow this issue seriously.
 
I don't think you read my post. This isn't about what you are talking about.

Do you mean they’re stupid enough not to know that the Want to Buy section is no index, even though they’re using it as a parasite to rank?
 
Do you mean they’re stupid enough not to know that the Want to Buy section is no index, even though they’re using it as a parasite to rank?
I am asking for the second time. Did you even read my original post?

Let me quote then:

  • Get the thread on the homepage in hopes that someone needs similar services and contacts you

And this is not just about WTB - This is about HAF too, and that entire section is indexed by Google.
 
I am asking for the second time. Did you even read my original post?

Let me quote then:

  • Get the thread on the homepage in hopes that someone needs similar services and contacts you

And this is not just about WTB - This is about HAF too, and that entire section is indexed by Google.

That’s a pretty superficial take. There won’t be that many people. I mean, what are the chances that someone interested in that work will see it on the homepage? Most of them want to rank at the top of Google.
 
Finally, a thread about this issue. I had no idea how bad it was until I posted a thread on there
Aside from the bots, it seems like most people are just there to get visibility on their threads, they'll respond claiming they can offer exactly what you're looking for, but once they DM you, suddenly they don't offer it and try to sell you something completely different

Majority also refuse to communicate on BHW and insist on moving the conversation to Telegram
I won't even get into the quality of the services or the nightmare of trying to claw back a refund when things go wrong

Never again
 
That’s a pretty superficial take. There won’t be that many people. I mean, what are the chances that someone interested in that work will see it on the homepage? Most of them want to rank at the top of Google.

I'm not exactly sure I understand you but why would we want fake threads ranking on Google and the first person responding using BHW as a parasite?

These HAF/WTB posts do absolutely litter the home page.

I think BHW suffers a lot from this issue. The home page used to be great. Now its not.
 
Back
Top