Pillar pages stop your posts from eating each other

SEOGami

Regular Member
Jr. VIP
Joined
Feb 28, 2024
Messages
236
Reaction score
163
I keep seeing sites publish a new post for every keyword and then wonder why none of them rank. This Semrush piece lays out the pillar page version of the fix, and the cannibalization section is the part worth reading.

A pillar is one overview URL for a whole topic. Cluster pages cover the subtopics and point back. Their example is an SEO hub that mentions technical SEO, link building, and local SEO, then sends people to separate pages for each.

They also say ChatGPT cites 1.26 pages per domain in a response. If that number holds, two similar posts on your site can compete for the citation the same way they compete in Google. I would not treat that as gospel until I see the method, but it matches what I see when two URLs share intent.

The internal link pattern they want is straightforward. The hub links to every cluster page. Every cluster page links to the hub. Related clusters link to each other when it actually helps.

Before I build another hub I would export the existing URLs, group them by intent, and merge the duplicates. A fat overview does nothing if the supporting posts already cover the same queries.

Hope some of you find it useful.

SEOGami
 
I keep seeing sites publish a new post for every keyword and then wonder why none of them rank. This Semrush piece lays out the pillar page version of the fix, and the cannibalization section is the part worth reading.

A pillar is one overview URL for a whole topic. Cluster pages cover the subtopics and point back. Their example is an SEO hub that mentions technical SEO, link building, and local SEO, then sends people to separate pages for each.

They also say ChatGPT cites 1.26 pages per domain in a response. If that number holds, two similar posts on your site can compete for the citation the same way they compete in Google. I would not treat that as gospel until I see the method, but it matches what I see when two URLs share intent.

The internal link pattern they want is straightforward. The hub links to every cluster page. Every cluster page links to the hub. Related clusters link to each other when it actually helps.

Before I build another hub I would export the existing URLs, group them by intent, and merge the duplicates. A fat overview does nothing if the supporting posts already cover the same queries.

Hope some of you find it useful.

SEOGami
similarly, I have also experienced the same phenomenon in certain niches where the various articles compete with each other for the slightly varying keyword. sometimes, you will need to split your clicks and impressions among different pages rather than concentrating all your efforts on one particular page alone. I personally use GSC to identify the pages that receive impressions through the same keyword to decide whether to consolidate them or leave them as separate articles. do you always use GSC for the same?
 
I concur with you that mapping out the keywords based on their search intent prior to the creation of additional pages can be an effective way of avoiding cannibalization Additionally a well defined pillar and cluster architecture will facilitate the process of internal linking
 
I keep seeing sites publish a new post for every keyword and then wonder why none of them rank. https://www.semrush.com/blog/pillar-page/ lays out the pillar page version of the fix, and the cannibalization section is the part worth reading.

A pillar is one overview URL for a whole topic. Cluster pages cover the subtopics and point back. Their example is an SEO hub that mentions technical SEO, link building, and local SEO, then sends people to separate pages for each.

They also say ChatGPT cites 1.26 pages per domain in a response. If that number holds, two similar posts on your site can compete for the citation the same way they compete in Google. I would not treat that as gospel until I see the method, but it matches what I see when two URLs share intent.

The internal link pattern they want is straightforward. The hub links to every cluster page. Every cluster page links to the hub. Related clusters link to each other when it actually helps.

Before I build another hub I would export the existing URLs, group them by intent, and merge the duplicates. A fat overview does nothing if the supporting posts already cover the same queries.

Hope some of you find it useful.

SEOGami
i m in agreement with the notion of combining similar pages before creatting new pages.in some cases, the issue is not about lack of content but too many pages working for something nearly the same.a well organized pillar page nd internal links will simplify navigation through the website.
 
I keep seeing sites publish a new post for every keyword and then wonder why none of them rank. https://www.semrush.com/blog/pillar-page/ lays out the pillar page version of the fix, and the cannibalization section is the part worth reading.

A pillar is one overview URL for a whole topic. Cluster pages cover the subtopics and point back. Their example is an SEO hub that mentions technical SEO, link building, and local SEO, then sends people to separate pages for each.

They also say ChatGPT cites 1.26 pages per domain in a response. If that number holds, two similar posts on your site can compete for the citation the same way they compete in Google. I would not treat that as gospel until I see the method, but it matches what I see when two URLs share intent.

The internal link pattern they want is straightforward. The hub links to every cluster page. Every cluster page links to the hub. Related clusters link to each other when it actually helps.

Before I build another hub I would export the existing URLs, group them by intent, and merge the duplicates. A fat overview does nothing if the supporting posts already cover the same queries.

Hope some of you find it useful.

SEOGami
Pillar pages and cluster content are a great way to prevent keyword cannibalization. Auditing existing URLs and organizing them based on search intent is equally important.
 
pillar pages fixed my cannibalization headache lol, one hub page and everything else just supports it imo
 
Publishing separate posts for every single keyword causes internal cannibalization that tanks rankings and fragments AI citations. Transitioning to a pillar-and-cluster architecture solves this by grouping subtopics around a central hub with strict internal linking. Before building a new hub, export your existing URLs, audit them by intent, and merge duplicate pages.
I keep seeing sites publish a new post for every keyword and then wonder why none of them rank. https://www.semrush.com/blog/pillar-page/ lays out the pillar page version of the fix, and the cannibalization section is the part worth reading.

A pillar is one overview URL for a whole topic. Cluster pages cover the subtopics and point back. Their example is an SEO hub that mentions technical SEO, link building, and local SEO, then sends people to separate pages for each.

They also say ChatGPT cites 1.26 pages per domain in a response. If that number holds, two similar posts on your site can compete for the citation the same way they compete in Google. I would not treat that as gospel until I see the method, but it matches what I see when two URLs share intent.

The internal link pattern they want is straightforward. The hub links to every cluster page. Every cluster page links to the hub. Related clusters link to each other when it actually helps.

Before I build another hub I would export the existing URLs, group them by intent, and merge the duplicates. A fat overview does nothing if the supporting posts already cover the same queries.

Hope some of you find it useful.

SEOGami
 
A lot of sites don’t need more articles they need a clearer structure and less overlap between URLs. Internal links help connect everything but they won’t fix cannibalization if several pages are answering the same question.
 
A lot of sites don’t need more articles they need a clearer structure and less overlap between URLs. Internal links help connect everything but they won’t fix cannibalization if several pages are answering the same question.

Worst mistake newbs make when buying templates

Most canned templates are an SEO nightmare

Make sure to clean up and do proper structure before going live

Ask AI to check the link structure if you must
 
I usually prefer GSC results first, I do check the existing pages first and if they are improving so I try finding more aspects around same topic before creating another article. More pages doesn't mean more traffic but it helps if you cover more aspects or points.
 
Back
Top