Anyone else seeing ranking changes since October 27?

Neylo

Neylo

Power Member
Jr. VIP
Joined
Jun 18, 2012
Messages
549
Reaction score
408
I've been seeing some volatility since October 27. Some of my websites have dropped, while others have jumped higher, so it's been a mixed bag.

What caught my attention was the mixed feedback from other site owners. Some were reporting better keyword positions without seeing more traffic, while others were talking about weaker traffic or conversions. A ranking jump looks good, but I'd want to see whether it brings any useful clicks before calling it a win.

Anyone else seeing similar movement across their sites?
 
Advertise on BHW
positions up but clicks flat is pretty much what i'd expect on queries that have an AI overview on top now. going from 6 to 4 under a big AI box doesn't change much. i'd check which queries actually moved before calling it a win or a loss
 
semrush sensor is off the charts

1793713917199.webp
 
Yes, it looks like some unconfirmed Google algorithm updates are rolling out, given the significant fluctuations we're seeing in search rankings. There are also some indications that Google may be preparing another major update in November/December, although nothing has been officially confirmed yet.
 
I notice everything is moving slow when it comes to indexing and ranking
 
I experience it as well, so I'm watching for now
 
I haven’t seen any changes in my blog yet. Its rankings have remained stable, with neither improvements nor declines.
 
Neylo said:
I've been seeing some volatility since October 27. Some of my websites have dropped, while others have jumped higher, so it's been a mixed bag.

What caught my attention was the mixed feedback from other site owners. Some were reporting better keyword positions without seeing more traffic, while others were talking about weaker traffic or conversions. A ranking jump looks good, but I'd want to see whether it brings any useful clicks before calling it a win.

Anyone else seeing similar movement across their sites?
Click to expand...
Yes, I have observed such variations too. Rankings by themselves do not give the complete picture.

I always like to analyze organic traffic, impressions, CTR, and conversions.

At times, the keyword may rise in rank, but if there is no improvement in search intent or CTR, then its business value is insignificant.
 
Neylo said:
I've been seeing some volatility since October 27. Some of my websites have dropped, while others have jumped higher, so it's been a mixed bag.

What caught my attention was the mixed feedback from other site owners. Some were reporting better keyword positions without seeing more traffic, while others were talking about weaker traffic or conversions. A ranking jump looks good, but I'd want to see whether it brings any useful clicks before calling it a win.

Anyone else seeing similar movement across their sites?
Click to expand...
however, I have noticed similar trends on some of my own websites as well. some keyword are becoming popular, while other keyword are losing their popularity, but there is no significant change in the traffic of my website. currently, all that I am doing is just watching the trend through GSC. perhaps, it is only a temporary trend.
 
Neylo said:
I've been seeing some volatility since October 27. Some of my websites have dropped, while others have jumped higher, so it's been a mixed bag.

What caught my attention was the mixed feedback from other site owners. Some were reporting better keyword positions without seeing more traffic, while others were talking about weaker traffic or conversions. A ranking jump looks good, but I'd want to see whether it brings any useful clicks before calling it a win.

Anyone else seeing similar movement across their sites?
Click to expand...
yes i have seen that somettimes the rankings nd traffic are not always synchronized.a rise in the ranking of a keyword by just a couple of positions does not matter much if there are no people coming to the website nd engaging with it.
 
look beyond average positions because a ranking increase doesn’t always translate into more clicks especially with AI Overviews and changing SERP layouts. I’d compare CTR and actual organic clicks in Search Console.
 
Neylo said:
I've been seeing some volatility since October 27. Some of my websites have dropped, while others have jumped higher, so it's been a mixed bag.

What caught my attention was the mixed feedback from other site owners. Some were reporting better keyword positions without seeing more traffic, while others were talking about weaker traffic or conversions. A ranking jump looks good, but I'd want to see whether it brings any useful clicks before calling it a win.

Anyone else seeing similar movement across their sites?
Click to expand...
similar situation can be found in several more websites. Keyword rank is either growing or going down nd the traffic stays almost the same. at this point, all I am doing is waiting for GSC to calm down within the next few weeks.
 
Neylo said:
I've been seeing some volatility since October 27. Some of my websites have dropped, while others have jumped higher, so it's been a mixed bag.

What caught my attention was the mixed feedback from other site owners. Some were reporting better keyword positions without seeing more traffic, while others were talking about weaker traffic or conversions. A ranking jump looks good, but I'd want to see whether it brings any useful clicks before calling it a win.

Anyone else seeing similar movement across their sites?
Click to expand...
yes the same situation can be observed on some of my websites. there have been fluctuations in some keyword both increase and decrease, but overall traffic remains the same. right now, I do not want to make any major alterations I would like to observe GSC for several more week.
 
Yes, ranking changes don’t always translate into more traffic. I’d compare impressions, clicks, and conversions in Search Console before deciding whether the movement is actually positive.
 
give it a few more days before changing anything Better rankings look nice but I’d want to see clicks and leads picking up too
 
Neylo said:
I've been seeing some volatility since October 27. Some of my websites have dropped, while others have jumped higher, so it's been a mixed bag.

What caught my attention was the mixed feedback from other site owners. Some were reporting better keyword positions without seeing more traffic, while others were talking about weaker traffic or conversions. A ranking jump looks good, but I'd want to see whether it brings any useful clicks before calling it a win.

Anyone else seeing similar movement across their sites?
Click to expand...
fluctuations have been noticed by me too. rankings keep fluctuating, however, there has not been any change in the traffic for my websites. At this point in time, I have been working on focusing on Google Search Console nd waiting for things to stabilize.
 
Neylo said:
I've been seeing some volatility since October 27. Some of my websites have dropped, while others have jumped higher, so it's been a mixed bag.

What caught my attention was the mixed feedback from other site owners. Some were reporting better keyword positions without seeing more traffic, while others were talking about weaker traffic or conversions. A ranking jump looks good, but I'd want to see whether it brings any useful clicks before calling it a win.

Anyone else seeing similar movement across their sites?
Click to expand...
Read this post https://www.blackhatworld.com/seo/s...-the-site-was-deindexed.1857349/post-21389149
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top