why do my edited videos still look amateurish ?

Sumeghaarya

BANNED
Joined
Mar 25, 2022
Messages
15
Reaction score
4
I think I’m pretty decent at video editing, but my finished products always seem to look a bit “casual.” What, in your opinion, makes an amateur edit look different from a professional one?
 
Timing, distance, and balance, is something you should be aware in all aspects of your video, have everything looks and itneracts itself on the micro and macro level. Go watch some videos that you see that impress you, and you should shout out "yipeekiyah" every time you see them changing some aspect of the video that isn't the flow of the video, instead something like the sounds, the brightness, the introduction of new aspects, speed, clipart type emoji, as many things as possilbe you'll notice. Write these down and copy them with variations, as if you were rewriting an article in your own handwriting.
 
Understanding how to cut well and apply professional transitions, your color correction(grading) and timely inserted B-rolls. These and others will amp your editing some notches
 
tbh sound design is the biggest giveaway. you can have the cleanest color grade but if the audio is flat or has harsh cuts between clips it just feels cheap... J-cuts and L-cuts help a lot with making things flow naturally.
 
Try adding sound effects. and buttons.
e.g. Swoosh sound effect whenever a button comes into the screen.
Sound effects play a major role while editing videos.
 
What kind of videos are you creating/editing? and what device are you using to record on? hard to answer without knowing what kind of videos youre making but you could try cinematic mode, and as other people have said the transitions play a big part, music too.
 
cut your footage in DaVinci Resolve 18, then apply a 3-stop lift in the color wheels, and render with H.264 at 24 fps 1080p, bitrate 12 Mbps; the default YouTube preset at 30 Mbps will make it look cheap
 
use a proper export preset like Premiere Pro's H.264 1080p 30 fps with a 12 Mbps target bitrate; the default low-bitrate preset leaves blocky artifacts, making the cut look cheap
 
If you lock your timeline to 24 fps and drop a LUT such as Osiris 6 in Premiere's Lumetri, the video instantly feels more polished than a casual edit.
 
Pro edits keep a fixed frame rate, use tight cuts on beat, and apply a calibrated color grade-set a 24 fps timeline in Premiere and load a LUT in the Lumetri Color panel. Adding simple lower thirds in After Effects and avoiding cheesy transitions also lifts the look.
 
Apply a LUT in DaVinci Resolve for consistent color grading; a flat color profile will make the footage look more cinematic. Tightening cut points and adding simple motion graphics in Premiere can also lift the polish.
 
I think I’m pretty decent at video editing, but my finished products always seem to look a bit “casual.” What, in your opinion, makes an amateur edit look different from a professional one?
as for that, in truth all you need is nothing elaborate such as transition nd special effects to have a polished editing job. the essential thing here is proper cutting of your film nd having all the elements right from color correction to perfect sound and timing.
 
If you lock your timeline to 24 fps and drop a LUT such as Osiris 6 in Premiere's Lumetri, the video instantly feels more polished than a casual edit.
A clean cinematic look can be achieved by combining 24fps with a proper LUT, but do not solely depend on the preset. I would start by adjusting the exposure, white balance, and skin tones; otherwise, the preset can overprocess the image.
 
Use a consistent color grade with a LUT in DaVinci Resolve and tighten cuts to the beat, also set audio peaks around -6 dB for a cleaner sound.
 
sometimes it's the small things tbh, like inconsistent fonts, random transitions or bad audio levels. i'd focus on clean cuts, smooth pacing and good sound before adding fancy effects. simple edits can look really professional when everything feels consistent.
 
Back
Top