Are High-DR Guest Post Sites Still Worth It If Their Traffic Is Dropping?

BlackShield

BlackShield

Elite Member
Jr. VIP
Joined
Jun 25, 2015
Messages
4,343
Reaction score
955
I have noticed some sites still have decent DR but their organic traffic has been flat or falling bit for months. Would you still consider them for guest posts if the niche is relevant, or is declining traffic a deal breaker for you?
 
Advertise on BHW
BlackShield said:
I have noticed some sites still have decent DR but their organic traffic has been flat or falling bit for months. Would you still consider them for guest posts if the niche is relevant, or is declining traffic a deal breaker for you?
Click to expand...
Low traffic doesn't automatically mean that the domain is not worth buying, but I would look into the cause of low traffic.

The domain should be relevant, have good content, and have some organic visibility for me to consider purchasing it.
 
BlackShield said:
I have noticed some sites still have decent DR but their organic traffic has been flat or falling bit for months. Would you still consider them for guest posts if the niche is relevant, or is declining traffic a deal breaker for you?
Click to expand...
IMO, it depends on the clients requirements and preferences. we consider those factors while choosing placements, but niche relevance and genuine traffic are what matter most to me.
 
BlackShield said:
I have noticed some sites still have decent DR but their organic traffic has been flat or falling bit for months. Would you still consider them for guest posts if the niche is relevant, or is declining traffic a deal breaker for you?
Click to expand...

depends on why it's dropping. if the site sank with the whole niche after an update and sells links carefully I'd still buy. but if the homepage has ten guest posts a day about casinos, crypto and kitchen remodeling, the drop is already a symptom and I'd skip that site
 
RoyRoyan said:
depends on why it's dropping. if the site sank with the whole niche after an update and sells links carefully I'd still buy. but if the homepage has ten guest posts a day about casinos, crypto and kitchen remodeling, the drop is already a symptom and I'd skip that site
Click to expand...
Agreed, I check the site’s history, traffic trend, and backlink profile first
A drop alone isn’t a dealbreaker, but clear signs of link selling across unrelated niches would make me skip it
 
Declining traffic is not always a deal breaker. I’d look at relevance and real audience value first rather than judging a site by DR alone.
 
Sarah Mathews said:
IMO, it depends on the clients requirements and preferences. we consider those factors while choosing placements, but niche relevance and genuine traffic are what matter most to me.
Click to expand...
yes thats true client requirements matter, but I always prioritize niche relevance and genuine organic traffic over just high DR or DA.
 
bogulater said:
Declining traffic is not always a deal breaker. I’d look at relevance and real audience value first rather than judging a site by DR alone.
Click to expand...
Exactly, I check the site’s relevance, traffic quality, and backlink profile before deciding. DR
 
SEO Sparton said:
Low traffic doesn't automatically mean that the domain is not worth buying, but I would look into the cause of low traffic.

The domain should be relevant, have good content, and have some organic visibility for me to consider purchasing it.
Click to expand...
ofcourse , I’d check why the traffic is low, along with the domain’s history, relevance, and backlink profile
 
I wouldn’t reject a site based on declining traffic alone I’d check which keywords lost rankings whether the remaining traffic is relevant to the niche and if the site still publishes quality content A steady decline across most relevant pages would make me more cautious
 
You can check whether the drop is across the whole domain or limited to certain pages, whether the site still ranks for relevant keywords, and if the decline looks gradual or sudden. If the site has genuine topical relevance, quality content, and a clean backlink profile, it may still be worth considering.
 
Flat is fine, but steadily fallin traffic is a deal breaker for me, bc it usually means Google’s quietly demotin the site n a link on a site that’s sinkin loses value fast, so I’d pass unless the drop’s clearly a one-off like a seasonal dip.
 
I’d look at the traffic trend before rejecting the site completely. If traffic is dropping across the whole domain for months, I’d be cautious. But if the site is still relevant and the specific page is getting visibility, it could still be worth considering.
 
BlackShield said:
I have noticed some sites still have decent DR but their organic traffic has been flat or falling bit for months. Would you still consider them for guest posts if the niche is relevant, or is declining traffic a deal breaker for you?
Click to expand...
I wouldn’t reject a site based on declining traffic alone. I’d also check content quality, niche relevance, and whether the site still gets genuine engagement. DR is just one metric, so I’d look at the overall picture before deciding.
 
BlackShield said:
I have noticed some sites still have decent DR but their organic traffic has been flat or falling bit for months. Would you still consider them for guest posts if the niche is relevant, or is declining traffic a deal breaker for you?
Click to expand...
I wouldn't reject them based on declining traffic alone. I'd check whether the drop is temporary, which pages lost traffic, and if the site still gets relevant organic visitors. If the traffic looks manipulated or the site's losing visibility across the board, I'd avoid it regardless of DR.
 
Nice question!

If a website is ranking for keywords related to my niche, I would definitely consider getting a guest post link from it.

A traffic drop alone is not a dealbreaker for me. Traffic naturally goes up and down, and I wouldn't reject a website just because its traffic has declined.

However, there are situations where I would avoid buying a guest post

-If the website has lost rankings across the board. If it has lost traffic for almost all its keywords, I would investigate further before spending money on it.

-If the website has become irrelevant to my niche. If it no longer ranks for relevant keywords and publishes content on random topics just to sell guest posts, I would avoid it.
-If the website's DR is high, but it has no real organic visibility. I wouldn't pay a premium just because a tool shows a high DR.
-If almost every article is sponsored content covering unrelated niches, that's a red flag for me.

For me, a traffic drop alone isn't enough to reject a website. I would look at what caused the drop, whether the website still has relevant search visibility, and whether the link is worth the price.

I wouldn't reject a site just because its traffic is dropping, but I wouldn't buy a link based on high DR alone either.

PS : Hope this helps many buyers here, as this is a common dilemma when buying guest posts from various sellers.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top